E
b
–bNb
B
—+BB}R d=*e
$H IQ ,H Q
,d˜
b
e;IOIH
~
b
–b
B
Nb
+
* d=*=e
HHIIH
!HJQHH,ded*e;I
–
B
h
+
; d=*Ce
B
HHI , d Me ,
IM;
+
IOHHI,IdMe,-J
IMR
P-HQHHIMHM
d
ed}e;IOJKH
–N
B
—+BB}R d=*:e
$H IQ ,H Q
,d˜He;IOIH
~
–
B
N
+
* d=*<e
H IQHIM , , O
IHHIM,;
)H,T0-d)
T
e
b
T
–w
T
Nx
T
; d=*Fe
w
T
IOLIIM T0-dH
He;
x
T
HILOT0-
HR
HI,I,-JOT0-d
T
e
T
–u
,N
„
–b
T
—'
T
—d+„
e; d=*Ge
u
,N
H HHI HM ,J
H;IQOJT0J-Jd*eR
IOHIMHMd*eR
'
T
HHIHJJHH;,JK T0
J-Jd*eR
E=
IO P- HIM ; ,JKM
IT0-R
HHQI
Q
–
∑
>=+
?
(@
>
2*
∗A
>
. *2
)
;
=*Ee
@
>
2 *
HHHJI,OJ-
V0JR
A
>
.* 2
IO KJ OH I V0
J*
4H,IM,db
B
e
dHeH,JHJKJ
B
B
=
∑
B
BC
;
d=*+Be
)
BT
H,- T0-,
Q,*
4 H , IM
db
+
edHeO,HHJK
B
+
=
∑
BDECFGE ¿+ H ¿
¿
¿
;
d=*+e
)
+”
H HJ H ”0 -
Q*
3I H HHI ,I IM
d
+
ed*e;H,H
,
+
=
∑
,
+ H
„
+Q
;„
PH
;
d=*+=e
+”
OHHI,I,-J ”0-
Q*
I KJK , PH PH
O H PH P; HI
PH IM O; H , ,H
HH*
@PHPH,,H-
HHI d1
e H ,HJ HJ HO HHIM
,IJ
EC
1
–h
—.
; d=*+Ce
O HMI ,-J ,
IM;*R
.
H HI PH IM
O*
H,
.
OHH
I;HHHI*.
I
B;+:JHM,H*.
OOHH
JPH IMO;OO
I*
IH,,PHPd1
e
H HHH HHJ PHM
,- - H ,HJ IM
OHIQ,H*
'HIPHIM,d.
e,
Q HJ HO , HHIM ,
,-JHHI
.
–N
* d=*+:e
H d)
&
e I H Q
IM,H,H1$HHOJ
HHIM,
)
&
–
N* d=*+<e
'HMI ,-J ,
-d
ed*eHHHHM
–
„
„
,
„
„Ž
PH
d=*+Fe
H,Hd*eR
HO,IIMd*eR
,
J HMI ,; H; H HM
HIMd*eR
H,IHd*e*
Ž
PH
,IHHPH-JHOd*e
42- ,+;# A&%,D, #)#B>%&$&?(;#+%&B>VV#% ('$&+ (A@&#% ,
E:
HH H H•; H , =*+; I
,•H•,PHPHH
,*
4 H •H , Q
,HHH;H=*+;HHI
-I MH , - ,
*
)-=*+
/H,-,
E
AMA
,(?#$&',$(#
&A#@,F((
"($(F,
(D?#@#$(<
Cdc?
@,C& H'
/&"
&@?,
'H@,C& %(
I&A#@,F(B';,+N
@!"&
c?%&+ *
+
'H-
4 =B:B G =G+;:
H 4 =+CB F CCG;:
=
HH
4 =+CB E =CE
C
H
4 ==B ++ =B
:
O
,J-
4 B B;G :
< HM 4 :B : +B
F H 4 + B;: C
G
HH
4 :B + :B
0 0
)-=*
/H,-
E
AMA
,(?#$&',$(#
&A#@,F((
"($(F,
(D?#@#$(<
Cdc?
@,C& H'
/&"
&@?,
'H@,C& %(
I&A#@,F(B';,+N
@!"&c?%&+ *
+
'H-
4 =B:B C: <F
H 4 =+CB G +:;:
=
HH
4 =+CB =: EB
C H 4 ==B =B ++
E<
:
O
,J-
4 B :B B;C
< HM 4 :B :: B;E
F H 4 + <B B;B+
G
HH
4 :B :B +
0 0
'HHI,•H,
H,JH IH , HJIM HIM
, ,; O H , ,* 'H• ,
HKHH;HI=*+;H*=*=*
4 H• HHIM , HHIH HH
IH,H*$HM,H
CB0HH,I+F:BB*
I
&
–+F:BB*Nd+*—Ge–+BC*N
)-=*=
'H•IM,PH
, @, H
$(O#$(#
D, @,
&>VV(
F(#$
(D?#$#$(<
@!"&'H=
D, @,
$"#%+
(D?#$#$(<
@!"&'H=
D, @,
,D&'HB
',@(,$
@&#% $HB
',@(,$
)•H
J
B
de
J
+
de
KJ=J
B
−J
+
de
L
J
=
KJ
J
B
M
J
=
J
B
J
+
+EF;F: E:;G+ +BB B;FF C;=G
H
,
B
d*e
,
+
d*e
K@=@
B
−@
+
d*e
L
@
=
K@
@
B
M
@
=
@
B
@
+
+=CE<< =BF<C +BCB B;FF C;=G
$, HHIM IM O H I ,
HKIMHHIM ,*KIM,
HJIOHH+BB*N;HKHHIM,
EF
hh+BCB**4I,IMHHIM,
HIH*=*+*=**HH*
Базовый вариант
Проектный вариант
0.00 200.00 400.00 600.00 800.00 1000.001200.001400.00
1297.00
295.00
Сравнение трудовых затрат
'H*=*+*4,IM,
EG
Базовый вариант
Проектный вариант
0 20000 40000 60000 80000 100000 120000 140000 160000
134966
30764
Сравнение стоимостных затрат
'H*=**4,HHIM,
'HH,IH,*6,
N
O /+
–BBBB*—:H*–+BBBBB*
1P
N
8
–:N*—+B:*—;++*–+++B*
$-IHHIdH$e
N
5
–FBB*—:H*–=:BB*
N
+
–+BBBBB*„+++B*„=:BB*–+BC<+B*
'HH I,I ,HHI*H
MH J; I I -
MH-HHdJHOHe;,I
HIJ*MH
EE
H Q,; M - H •H
CBBB*Q,=BBB*
N
+
–CBBB*„=BBB*„+BC<+B–+CE<+B*
'HHHH
J
"
–+CE<+B*N+BCB*™+;C™+<;GH*
)HHPHP*@P
QHHOJHHIM,*
8
–+BCB*h+CE<+B*—B;+:–G+F<+*
&H;+<;GH-;,I,H
OH IM O* )O P O
I PH P; I G+F<+ *
HHI,H,IHHI,IFF}*
•IH•I,JHIIHPH
,*
I I H PH
PH HHI H , HO
HHIMIM,;OHH*
+BB
,%)S;#$(#
IH - ,IH HH
P&&&8@ &H9*
, - HH ,
PHKHIHJH*
$H, HHI , H -
-,HMPJ
HHH-IM*
!H H I HO J MH
HH* HIH ,-
H H MH HIM ,H0
-HH* 6H O HIH ,- ,H0-HH; H
H ,H0-HH IH H HIM -HHM;
MIMHH*
HH-HHI*
6H O HI 0H , -;
I - H- HHI; H HM
;HIHII*
I M HH
,I OI HJ,H;
IOJKJH ,H , H, IM
,*
'HPHPH,;H,
HH +G H-; H H
PH II H , HO IM HHIM
,*
I H HO HHI ,J HH
;HJ H, ‡U| 0M 0 HH
HH -I H; H HJK
HO HHI JM , H 0
IHJ HH -, H, HHI;
+B+
OI,H-HHI,OH
IH0IHHHO,0=H-PH-;
H, Q H M H HKH
PHMI*
),;HI,IH-I“
, H ; I HKHJKM H
K M ; , , HHI
P;II*
*