88
@ 4 3 '! ! 35
!35 &4 3 3 ?2 ( >> '
?!35&2
Рисунок 44 График снижения трудовых затрат
( >M ' ? ! !35 &2 (
'35 !. 34 !!3
'&3.32??'2
Рисунок 45 График снижения стоимостных затрат
6 & ! '! '2 @ .
" &3 & ?!" !32 !3
'3 &3& !3 +
)
3
'?!M2
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
До автоматизации
После автоматизации
Человеко-часов
Динамика трудозатрат
0
50000
100000
150000
200000
250000
300000
350000
До автоматизации
После автоматизации
Рублей
Динамика стоимостных затрат
89
+++=
+
M
)! ?! & & '4
'!!4 4 '3 &32 *3
'4 '!!4 3 &
'"4&355'"5&
3' 5 '"2 " & '!
! ' "2 !3 &3 3 ' !
&32
'
•<M1U’N1•0N1112
'
•<M1U’7Q0•L10112
‡
•<M1U’>1•7>1112
!!'35&''
&3352
'
•<Q7112
+
'
•0N111‡L1011‡7>111‡<Q711•7<O<11
2
!'!'P
8
•7<O<11U7OO111•14Q
'3!!'!33!
&"4 '! !3 ' .
35 & 0L1 9 <MŠ . !35
& 71M M11 <>Š2 !3 &3 ' '!
.4!'&!74M>&43&3''!
.&3574M<&2'!'14Q4
& ' ' '3 ' .
2
90
@
%()) *)+,
[ 011< 2 3! '! &"
'&'""'"&2(
'' = 3?"35 '"4 3
&3 & '& '" "
&2 6 5 '& '' &
3 4 ! '. !
'. 5 4 & !. 3 &!.
&&"2
6&"'!!'24
!&3 4 ' !.3
!265''33&
5 ' T '" '
&!2 8&3 '" 3 &
!. !4 !35 & !!"4 '
'5 = !. ! &" !
' ' 3' '35 &2 6 5 3 3
'3 3& ' 5!3 &
''!!'2(53
'=!&"2
W3 '!!3 = '& '3!
?"3!4 ?3! 5! !4 '! 3
'=& '!! '!
#89 &"4 35 '3 & '.
'!!'2
& '!! '
W8#UV+7001Q901714'!.&"
%'3 ',2 ( ' ' 3
' ' & '!! '
' &!4 3 3 ' 5!35
'!!35 55 2 6 4 ?"
91
!3 5! &3 35 !'!4
3 '& ! 5 '&
!&&!32
( ' & '!! ' 3 &
?!" !4 3 5 54 '!4 9
'35?!"2(3553
&3 !3 ?! '!! '2 = ' ?"
!3 '3 ?" " 2 *! 3
&"&354'"52
& ! ! ! 4 ' '!!35
! 3 ' 3& '!!35 !
!532
6 & ' 3 3 & ?!"
!4'&!&&4!3'
&4!!?!32!
! 3 !3 &3 3' &
3535?!2
#! ' 3 ! ??
'2 @ 3 3 3 !3 &3
'" ' &!2
'3! ! ' ! 33!
&"4'!!3'.35
&0L19<MŠ.!35&
71MM11<>Š2!3&3''!.4
! ' &!74M>&4 3&3''!.
&35 74M< &2 '!' 14Q 4 &
'''3'.2
92
72 W8 #UV+ 7001Q901712 #?!" 52
! '!! .2 )"3 .& "
'!!352
02 C C2$24 W& 8262 ) ?!"35
!2&"2TV2PA4017O2T0M02
<2 C 6262 6 ?!" &'
!&35!2TV2PVW8-!2(22C!4017N2T0M02
>2 6 $2$2 3 ?!" &'2 *
?!"2TV2Pg4017O2T0>12
M2 6 62(2 8 ?!"35 '" !2 9 V2P
g4017N2T><02
L2 W A2W2 & '" !&35
?!"35!2TV2P#?9V4!4017N2T<N>2
Q2 W& 62$24 A #2g2 3 '
!&35?!"35 !2 TV2P#?9V4 !4 017N2 T
<7N2
N2 W& 82624 C C2$2 ) ?!"35
!2 85 !& '2 T V2P A4 017N2 T
7ML2
O2 W +24 ( 2 '! &9!2 h3
!'!2TV2P$')=4017>2T07L2
712 *!5 2)2 #?!"3 !3P '
.&3!"!4017O2TV2Pg2T><72
772 + 6262 ) ?!"35 !2 T V2P
!4017N2T<012
702 +' 62$24 +' 622 #?!"3 !3
!2TV2P)'4017N2T7702
7<2 V= 2$24 ! 62A24 ;' V2A2 C&3 352
) '! -C@ Ybc ‰]Yyc9' '!
'?!"35!2TV2P!49017N2T<LN2
93
7>2 5 $2624 (2 2 ) ?!"35
!2TV2PA4017O2T7L>2
7M2 ) 62#24 V" #262 * '35 35
?!"35!52TV2PA4017O2T71N2
7L2 3. $2(24 3. (2$24 A (2V2 !
?!"35!2TV2Pg4017O2T7QL2
7Q2 8?! 6262 #?!"3 !3 5
!'2TV2Pg4017N2T<0>2
7N2 ” 62 24 W $262 -' !2 -
'6-*2TV2Pg4017Q2T7N02
7O2 l„]x`lYl‰lF3GPlYl‰lUUF?"2G2•ScP
}``s^PUUr^rnr2[]~Us\]ox[`@P7021Q2017O2
012 •r^d[r~sP s\]Žd[` ~rnr{d~dn` rno `dr~ F3 GP
•r^d[r~s UU F?"2 G2 •ScP }``s^PUU„r^d[r~s2[]~U @ P
7021Q2017O2
072 ynwZnd vdr~ |]wwr„]\r`Z]n Y]_`pr\d F3 GP
Sdo„]]`}UU F?"2 G2 •ScP }``s^PUU\do„]]`}2[]~U @ P
7021Q2017O2
002 !! W ' &! F3
GPUUzrnn`k\]F?"2G2•ScP}``s^PUU{rn``s\]2[]~U\xU@P
7021Q2017O2
0<2 )!! ' . & '
F3 GP UU …Z\r F?"2 G2 •ScP
}``s^PUU\x2r`wr^^Zrn2[]~U^]_`pr\dUŽZ\r@P7021Q2017O2
94
/
A'!!
V&"
vK]\~lx`}`]\Zƒr`Z]n’K]\~lx`}`]\Zƒr`Z]nR
„]]wK^d\[}ln^ZY`\Zn{K•
K]\~lx`}]\Zƒr`Z]n9•cr„dwc]{Zn9•KZ\^`R
_]\Zn`Z•1RZ–K]\~lx`}]\Zƒr`Z]n9•cr„dwc]{Zn9•S]p|]xn`RZ‡‡•
Z_K••K]\~lx`}]\Zƒr`Z]n9•cr„dwc]{Zn9•ˆrwxd
•
\d`x\n`\xdR
_]\Zn`Z•1RZ–K]\~lx`}]\Zƒr`Z]n9•cr„dwkr^^p]\o9•S]p|]xn`RZ‡‡•
Z_K••K]\~lx`}]\Zƒr`Z]n9•cr„dwkr^^p]\o9•ˆrwxd
•
\d`x\n`\xdR
„\drtR
—
K]\~lx`}]\Zƒr`Z]n9•cr„dwc]{Zn9•‰dŒ`R—
\d`x\n_rw^dR
—
UU999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999
W3!
_r^`[rwwvK\~XrZnPPvK\~XrZnvy„Žd[`^’•^d\
PvK]\~XrZn
•
—
UU999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999
e]Zo_r^`[rwwvK]\~XrZnPP|\dr`d|wZ[tvy„Žd[`’•^d\
•
K]\~XrZ~9•K]\~Sd‹xd^`9•ysdnR
UUZ_K^d\[}_|wZdn`9•vdŒ`|\dr`d|wZdn`•˜`\xd˜Rdw^d|\dr`d|wZdn`˜_rw^d˜R
Z_ K^d\[}_Sd‹xd^`9•vdŒ`•• _rw^d †† _vusdSd‹xd^`9•vdŒ`••_loo\d^^9
•vdŒ`††_Sd‹xd^`9•|rs`Z]n••_vusdSd‹xd^`9•vdŒ`•
95
roo9•Ybc9•|wdr\R
roo9•Ybc9•loo˜H‰YJSv H‰vy Sd‹xd^`‰]~4 vusds\]„wd~4 vZ~d ˆlc•JY
™˜‡‰x~„d\Sd‹xd^`9•vdŒ`‡˜™4™˜‡vusdk\]„wd~9•vdŒ`‡˜™4™˜‡vZ~d9•‰]p‡˜™˜R
roo9•JŒd[YbcR
K]\~XrZn9•K]\~Sd‹xd^`9•|w]^dR
—dw^dY}]pXd^^r{d˜J\\]\˜R
—
V''&!
UU999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999
šZn[wxod–•^d\^2}•
šs\r{~r}o\^`]s
šZn[wxod˜•^d\^2}˜
UU999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999
šs\r{~rsr[tr{d^~r\`ZnZ`
šs\r{~r\d^]x\[d˜’2o_~˜
vK]\~•^d\^’K]\~•^d\^R
ˆr\Zrn`eˆr\•^d\‰r~d4eˆr\c]{Zn4eˆr\Sxwd^4^}R
UU999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999
_r^`[rwwvK]\~•^d\^PPvK]\~•^d\^v|]~s]ndn`’ypnd\
PvK]\~•^d\^ypnd\
•
—
UU999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999
e]Zo_r^`[rwwvK]\~•^d\^PP•x``]n|\dr`d|wZ[tvy„Žd[`’Ydnod\
•
eˆr\•^d\‰r~d•|\dr`dy„Žd[`˜•^d\˜R
eˆr\c]{Zn•eˆr\•^d\2ywdk\]sd\`uzd`˜c]{Zn˜R
eˆr\Sxwd^2ywdk\][dox\d˜Sxwd^˜R
96
eˆr\Sxwd^2ywdk\][dox\d˜Yred˜R
eˆr\kr^^p]\o•eˆr\I][2ywdk\]sd\`uzd`˜zdnd\r`d˜R
HnY`][t˜›7˜4JoZ`•^d\‰r~d9•vdŒ`R
HnY`][t˜›0˜4Jo=@'=9•vdŒ`R
eˆr\lss2ywdk\]sd\`uYd`˜ˆZ^Z„wd˜4`\xdR
—
UU999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999
V'
šZ_nod_~rZn_~‚
šod_Znd~rZn_~‚
UU999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999
šZn[wxod–|wr^^d^2}ss•
šZn[wxod–|]n`\]w^2}ss•
šZn[wxod–Y`o|`\w^2}ss•
šZn[wxod–K]\~^2}ss•
šZn[wxod–|]~|`\w^2}ss•
šZn[wxod˜~rZno~2}˜
šZn[wxod–I•z\Zo^2}ss•
šZn[wxod–z\Zo^2}ss•
UU999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999
[wr^^v_~XrZnPsx„wZ[vK]\~Ys\
•
vo~XrZn’o~XrZnR
vI•z\Zo’_r^`[rww{d`|x\\dn`z\ZoR
sx„wZ[PUU•^d\od[wr\r`Z]n^
_r^`[rwwv_~XrZnv|]~s]ndn`’ypnd\R
_r^`[rwwv_~XrZnv|]~s]ndn`’ypnd\4vlIy|]nnd[`Z]n’o„R
sx„wZ^}doPUUHIJ9~rnr{do|]~s]ndn`^
vkr{d|]n`\]w’s{XrZnR
e]Zo_r^`[rwws{XrZn|}rn{dvy„Žd[`’Ydnod\R
e]Zo_r^`[rwwK]\~I„w|wZ[tvy„Žd[`’Ydnod\R
s\Zer`dPUU•^d\od[wr\r`Z]n^
97
—R
UU999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999
dŒ`d\nkl|qlzJv_~Ys\’_~Ys\R
UU999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999
šdnoZ_
UU2[ss
UU999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999
šZn[wxod–e[w2}•
šs\r{~r}o\^`]s
šZn[wxod˜^s\K]\~2}˜
šZn[wxod˜_]\~Ys\2}˜
UU999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999
šs\r{~rsr[tr{d^~r\`ZnZ`
šs\r{~r\d^]x\[d˜’2o_~˜
v_~Yk\’_~Ys\R
UU999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999
_r^`[rwwv_~Ys\PPv_~Yk\v|]~s]ndn`’ypnd\4vlIy|]nnd[`Z]n’o„
PvK]\~ypnd\4o~Ys\ypnd\4o„
•
o~Ys\9•w]rokr{d^`}Z^9•s{Ys\R
o~Ys\9•w]roSd_d\dn[d{d`|x\\dn`z\ZoR
—
UU999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999
vI•z\Zo’_r^`[rwwv_~Ys\PP{d`|x\\dn`z\Zo
•
Z_s{Ys\9•l[`Zedkr{dHnodŒ••97\d`x\nR
vI•Ys\’o„•‰•ccR
_]\Zn`Z•1RZ–`}Z^9•|]~s]ndn`|]xn`R‡‡Z•
Z_`}Z^9•|]~s]ndn`^9•|wr^^‰r~d‘•˜vI•z\Zo˜[]n`ZnxdR