R"!
!
+'%3'2%3','!(0,)'7-!)K>K-!%6P0%&26OP)W!',(-7)/07)C!70!+',6&!'H0(-&)27'!
H('20()&N! H'J1)77'%&N! J'36+07&'2! +),(-.)'77','! 6/c&-S! G&-+H'2! '!
H0(0%0/07))! ,(-7).V! )! J-^0! 2)KS! 0%1)! Z&)! J'36+07&V! 2VJ-7V! 2! J(6,'+!
(0,)'70#!
!U,(-7)/07)0!J'%&6H-!3!)7B'(+-.))!&(-J).)'77'!2!%(0J0!%)1'2)3'2!)K>
K-! )W! %2'0'X(-K7VW! H(0J%&-2107)C! '! %03(0&7'%&)S! 2K-)+7'C! 620(077'%&)!
H(-2''W(-7)&010C! 2! &'&-1N7'C! 3'((6+H)('2-77'%&)! )! )%H'1NK'2-7))!
%16^0X7'C!)7B'(+-.))!2!70!H(0J6%+'&(077VW!K-3'7'+!.01*W#!:-7)H61*.))!
J-77V+)! 2! %16^0X7VW! X-K-W! :[A! 7-! Z&'+! 6('270! 2'K+'^7V! 2! H(0J01-W!
&0W7)/0%3)W! H'17'+'/)C! '3'70/7VW! 'H0(-&'('2#! F-! Z&'+! 6/-%&30! J'1^7-!
XV&N! H('20J07-! .)B('2-*! (0B'(+-S! )%31O/-OP-*! 3-3! X-(N0(7VCS! &-3! )!
3'((6H.)',077VC!ZBB03&!H0(%'7-1-!:[AS!2%&6H-OP0,'!2!70H'%(0J%&2077VC!
3'7&-3&!%!H()7)+-OP0C!%&'('7'C#!d('20(3)!H'!X-K-+!J-77VW!)!H'%&-7'23-!7-!
+),(-.)'77VC! 6/c&! J'1^7V! XV&N! H'17'%&NO! -2&'+-&)K)('2-7VS! 'H0(-&'(V!
J'1^7V!XV&N!'&J0107V!'&!K-*2)&010C#!
:),(-.)'77VC!6/c&!2!%'2(0+077VW!6%1'2)*W!h!Z&'!70!J'36+07&!)!70!
K-H)%N!2!X-K0!J-77VWS!Z&'!3''(J)7-&V!,0'1'3-.))S!H0(0J-2-0+V0!&010B'7'+!
0,'!21-J01N.-!2!7'/7'0!)!1OX'0!J(6,'0!2(0+*!%6&'3#!A0H0(%'7)B).)('2-77V0!
J-77V0!'!+0%&'7-W'^J07))!)!H0(0+0P07))!&010B'7'2S!J-77V0!'!H'20J07))!2!
%0&)S! '! %'20(G-0+VW! H1-&0^-W! J-O&! 70%(-27)+'! X'100! &'/76O! )! .0776O!
)7B'(+-.)OS!/0+!%)%&0+-!+),(-.)'77','!6/c&-#!M)%&0+-!3'7&('1*!+),(-.))!
J'1^7-! XV&N! '%7'2-7-! 7-! &-3','! ('J-! J-77VW#! $J07&)B)3-.)*! )! H('20(3-!
J'%&'20(7'%&)! )7B'(+-.))! J'1^7V! '%6P0%&21*&N%*! %! H'+'PNO!
%''&20&%&26OP)W!-1,'()&+'2S!6/)&V2-OP)W!&-3)0!B-3&'(VS!3-3!X-73'2%3)0!
J-77V0S!,0'J-77V0!)!J-77V0!'!(0,61*(7'C!6H1-&0!%''&20&%&26OP)W!H1-&0^0C!
2! XOJ^0&! ;'%%)C%3'C! I0J0(-.))#! d()! Z&'+! )7B'(+-.)'77-*! H('K(-/7'%&N!
%&-70&! `61).0C! %! J26%&'('77)+! J2)^07)0+a! >! ,'%6J-(%&2'! &-3^0! J'1^7'!
%J01-&N!H6X1)/7'C!H'16/-0+6O!%!H'+'PNO!+),(-7&'2!-7-1)&)36#!
d()'()&0&7V+)! 3()+)7'1',)/0%3)+)! +0(-+)! H('&)2'J0C%&2)*!
70K-3'77'C! +),(-.))! *21*0&%*! .)B('2)K-.)*! )! B)%3-1)K-.)*! lH()2*K3-!
R5!
!
,'%6J-(%&2077VW! 6%16,! 3! X-73'2%3)+! %/0&-+! K-*2)&010Cm! 2K-)+'J0C%&2)C!
,(-^J-7! %! ,'%6J-(%&2'+#! \&)! +0(V! H'K2'1*&! H'16/)&N! J'%&'20(76O!
)7B'(+-.)O! '! /)%1077'%&)S! ,0',(-B)/0%3'+! (-%H(0J0107))! )! J)7-+)30!
H0(0J2)^07)*!+),(-7&'2#!
_)B('2)K-.)*! *21*0&%*! ,1'X-1N7V+! H('.0%%'+S! 3'&'(VC! 2! %2'c+!
(-K2)&))!2!'XP0,(-^J-7%3'+!'X'('&0!2!H'2%0J7027'C!^)K7)!J-27'!'H0(0J)1!
(-K2)&)0! )! H('7)37'207)0! ,'%6J-(%&2077VW! =¢#! `[V%'3-*! 1-&07&7'%&Na!
B)3&)27VW! (0,)%&(-.)CS! 3-+H-7))! H'! X'(NX0! %! `(0K)7'2V+)! 32-(&)(-+)aS!
6('207N! )KJ0(^03! H()! 'B'(+107))! +),(-.)'77VW! J'36+07&'2! )!
(-%%10J'2-7)*!B-3&'2!B-1N%)B)3-.)C!)!3'((6H.))!2!'&7'G07))!%'&(6J7)3'2!
:[A! H'3-KV2-0&S! /&'! :[A! 70! '&20/-0&! %'2(0+077V+! &(0X'2-7)*+! )! 70! 2!
%'%&'*7))!'X0%H0/)&N!%'2(0+077VC!&0W7'1',)/0%3)C!6('207N!(-X'&V!%)%&0+!
+),(-.)'77','!6/c&-!)!3'7&('1*#!!
d()7)+-OP-*!%&'('7-!lB)K)/0%3'0! 1).'m! J'1^7-! )+0&N! 2'K+'^7'%&N!
)J07&)B).)('2-&N! %0X*! )! %&-2)&N! )7'%&(-77VW! ,(-^J-7! 7-! +),(-.)'77VC!
6/c&! '71-C7S! X0K! 1)/7','! H()%6&%&2)*! ,J0>1)X'#! M)++0&()/7'0! H(-2'! )!
&0W7)/0%3-*! 2'K+'^7'%&N! J'1^7V! XV&N! )! 6! )7'%&(-77','! ,(-^J-7)7-#!
Q-^JVC!H'1NK'2-&01N!%)%&0+V!l,(-^J-7)7!;'%%))S!)7'%&(-77VC!,(-^J-7)7!
)1)!1).'!X0K!,(-^J-7%&2-m!J'1^07!)+0&N!2'K+'^7'%&N!)J07&)B).)('2-&N%*!)!
20%&)! 2%c! 'XP07)0! '&! %2'0,'! )+07)! 2! Z103&('77'C! B'(+0#! A'1^7'! XV&N!
H(0J6%+'&(07'! Z103&('77'0! H(0J%&-2)&01N%&2'! )7&0(0%'2! ,(-^J-7!
%H0.)-1)%&-+)#! ]'%6J-(%&2'! 2! Z&'+! %16/-0! X6J0&! )+0&N! X'100! J'%&'20(7V0!
J-77V0#!
`;0K)7'2V0! 32-(&)(Va! )! J(6,)0! '&31'707)*! '&! 7'(+V! /)%1077'%&)!
)7'%&(-77VW! ,(-^J-7! H'! 3-3'+6>1)X'! -J(0%6! 2V*21*O&%*! &-3)+! 'X(-K'+! 2!
-2&'+-&)/0%3'+! (0^)+0#! :0^20J'+%&2077V0! X-KV! J-77VW! J'1^7V!
%)7W('7)K)('2-&N%*! 2! (0^)+0! '71-C7! %! +)7)+-1N7V+)! 2(0+077V+)!
K-J0(^3-+)#!L!)7'%&(-77VW!,(-^J-7S!H()7)+-OP)W!)!H(),1-G-OP)W!%&'('7!
J'1^7-! XV&N! 2'K+'^7'%&N! %10J)&N! K-! %2')+! %&-&6%'+! '71-C7S! H'16/-&N! )!
'H1-/)2-&N!G&(-BV!%!H'+'PNO!H()1'^07)C!7-!&010B'70#!
R9!
!
!UB'(+107)0!+),(-.)'77','!6/c&-!J'1^7'!XV&N!-7-1',)/7'!H('.0J6(0!
'B'(+107)*!H'%-J'/7','!&-1'7-!7-!-2)-(0C%!%!+'X)1N7','!&010B'7-#!U71-C7!
-7-1)K!%'X)(-0+VW!&-3)+!'X(-K'+!J-77VW!'!K-,(6^077'%&)!70J2)^)+'%&)!J1*!
H'%&'*77','!)!2(0+077','!H('^)2-7)*!2V*2)&!B)3&)27V0!(0,)%&(-.))#!A1*!
2%02'K+'^7VW!H('20('3!70'XW'J)+'!)%H'1NK'2-&N!-3&6-1N76O!%'2(0+0776O!
)7B'(+-.)O! )! 3-7-1V! %2*K)S! -! 70! H'/&6! ;'%%))S! )! 70! -J(0%-! )! 7'+0(-!
%&-.)'7-(7VW! &010B'7'2S! 3',J->&'! 63-K-77V0! H()! (0,)%&(-.)'77VW!
J0C%&2)*W#! f3&6-1N7V+)! 7-! %0,'J7*G7)C! J07N! *21*O&%*! +'X)1N7-*! %2*KN! )!
Z103&('77-*!H'/&-#!
!A1*!%7)^07)*!1-&07&7'%&)S!�#!616/G07)*!`2)J)+'%&)a!70^01-&01N7VW!
H('.0%%'2S! H(0J%&-21*0&%*! .010%''X(-K7V+! H()7*&N! +0(V! H'! %7*&)O!
'H(0J01077VW! 276&()>! )! +0^20J'+%&2077VW! )! +0^(0,)'7-1N7VW!
',(-7)/07)CS! )! )7&0,(-.))! (0,)'7-1N7VW! X-K! J-77VW! H',(-7)/7','! )!
+),(-.)'77','! 6/c&-#! A-77V0! +0(V! +'^7'! '&70%&)! 3! +0(-+! 276&()>! )!
+0^20J'+%&2077','! 2K-)+'J0C%&2)*S! 3-3! /-%&7'+6! %16/-O!
3()+)7'1',)/0%3)W!+0(#!
M10J6OP)+! G-,'+! J'1^07! %&-&N! '&3-K! '&! X6+-^7','!
J'36+07&''X'('&-#! d'JJ013-! J'36+07&'2! +'^0&! H(')K2'J)&N%*! &'1N3'! H()!
'&%6&%&2))!6!3'7&(-,07&'2!2'K+'^7'%&)!H('20(3)!J'36+07&'2#![!Z&'C!'X1-%&)!
,'%6J-(%&2'! K7-/)&01N7'! '&%&-1'! '&! %'2(0+077VW! &0W7'1',)C#! F-H()+0(S!
)%H'1NK60+VW! X-73-+)! )1)! -2)-3'+H-7)*+)#! I-1N%)B)3-.)*! J-77VW! 2!
Z103&('77VW!X-K-W!3-(J)7-1N7'!6%1'^7*0&!^)K7N!K1'6+VG1077)3-+S!&-3!3-3!
H'+)+'! X'100! 2V%'3','! 6('27*! &0W7)/0%3'C! %1'^7'%&)! &-3^0! 70+)760+'!
'%&-21*0&! +7'^0%&2'! %10J'2! )! (0K3'! 6201)/)2-0&! ()%3)! J1*!
H(-2'7-(6G)&010C#!
$+00&! %+V%1! -2&'+-&)K)('2-&N! 3-3! +'^7'! X'1NG6O! /-%&N! B673.)C!
:[AS! %J01-&N! H('K(-/7'C! J0*&01N7'%&N! (0,)'7-1N7VW! H'J(-KJ0107)C! J(6,!
J1*!J(6,-!)!J1*!'XP0%&2-#!A'1^7-!XV&N!'X0%H0/07-!'H0(-&)27-*!-3&6-1)K-.)*!
)!%)7W('7)K-.)*!(0,)'7-1N7VW!X-K!J-77VW#!
!LH('P07)0!)!'X10,/07)0!3'++67)3-.)C!%!,'%6J-(%&2'+S!-!&-3^0!+0^J6!
R@!
!
,'%'(,-7-+)! (-K1)/7VW! 6('270C! %! H'+'PNO! M:\[! )! %'2(0+077VW!
+'X)1N7VW! H()1'^07)C! 6^0! H'3-KV2-0&! +7','3(-&7'0! H(02'%W'J%&2'! 7-J!
%6P0%&26OP0C!%)%&0+'C#!
![76&()! :[AS! 3-3! H'3-KV2-0&! H(-3&)3-S! 70&! J'%&-&'/7VW! %)1S!
K-)7&0(0%'2-77VW! 2! (0B'(+0! %1'^)2G0C%*! %)%&0+VS! H'Z&'+6! '/07N! 2-^7-!
270G7**! )7).)-&)2-S! ^01-&01N7'! )K! )%&'/7)3'2S! 231O/-OP)W! 70! &'1N3'!
)7%&)&6&V!,'%6J-(%&2-S!7'!)!)7%&)&6&V!,(-^J-7%3','!'XP0%&2-#!
!
9#@#!I)%3-1)K-.)*!2K-)+'J0C%&2)C!%!,'%6J-(%&2'+!3-3!
3()+)7'1',)/0%3-*!+0(-!H('&)2'J0C%&2)*!70K-3'77'C!+),(-.))#!
UHV&! H'3-KV2-0&S! /&'! %)&6-.)*! 2! %B0(0! 3'7&('1*! &0W! )1)! )7VW! %B0(!
K-2)%)&! '&!&','S! 3-3-*! )K!%&'('7!X'100! ZBB03&)27'! H()+07*0&! %'2(0+077V0!
&0W7'1',))#! o%1)! 2! %16/-0! +'7)&'()7,-! 7-(6G07)C! dAA! )! %+0(&7'%&)! 7-!
J'(',-W!H(')K'G1)!3-(J)7-1N7V0!616/G07)*S!&'!2!J(6,)W!'X1-%&*W!H('X10+-!
6G1-! %! 61).! 2! )7&0(70&S!,J0! %&-1-! +0700! 2)J)+'C#! [! <<=! 2030! 2%0! &0702V0!
(V73)!2!&'C!)1)!)7'C!%&0H07)!H0(0+0%&)1)%N!2!%0&N#!d()+0(!&-3','!H0(0W'J-!
i!),'(7VC!X)K70%S!3'&'(VC!702K)(-*!7-!K-H(0&!'(,-7)K-.))!-K-(&7VW!),(!)!)W!
(031-+V! lLQ! ;I! M&-&N*! "4"#5#! `F0K-3'77V0! '(,-7)K-.)*! )! H('20J07)0!
-K-(&7VW!),(a!>!G&(-B!J'!"SE!+17!(6X10C!)!1)G07)0!%2'X'JV!J'!G0%&)!10&m!)!
+7','/)%1077V0! X1'3)('23)! ;'%3'+7-JK'(-! H0(0%&-1! XV&N! J'%*,-0+V+! J1*!
,'%6J-(%&2-!)!H('.20&-0&!2!%0&)#!
! [-^7'C!3()+)7'1',)/0%3'C!K-J-/0C!H'!H('&)2'J0C%&2)O!70K-3'77'C!
+),(-.))!*21*0&%*!вывод её из тени#!\&'!'K7-/-0&!+-3%)+-1N7'0!6H('P07)0!
)! 'X10,/07)0! H('.0J6(! +),(-.)'77','! 6/c&-S! /&'! 2! %2'O! '/0(0JN! &(0X60&!
H'2VG07)*! H('K(-/7'%&)! (-X'&V! ,'%'(,-7'2! )! H0(0J-/)! (*J-! B673.)C! '&!
:[A! 3! I0J0(-1N7'C! F-1','2'C! M16^X0! )! %H0.)-1)K)('2-77V+S!
2V%'3'-2&'+-&)K)('2-77V+! ,'%6J-(%&2077V+! XOJ^0&7V+! 6/(0^J07)*+S!
%'KJ-2-0+V+!%H0.)-1N7'!H'J!J-77V0!K-J-/)#!F-H()+0(S!+'7)&'()7,!6H1-&V!
(-X'&'J-&01*+)! )7'%&(-77VW! ,(-^J-7! 7-1',-! 7-! J'W'JV! B)K)/0%3)W! 1).!
lFAIqm! H'K2'1)&! (0G)&N! H('X10+6! `1)H'2VW! [QMa! l%&-&N*! "9#5!
RE!
!
I0J0(-1N7','! K-3'7-! ›! ""E>Ib! `U! H(-2'2'+! H'1'^07))! )7'%&(-77VW!
,(-^J-7am!>!&'!0%&N!H('X10+V!2VJ-/)!(-X'/)W!2)K!)7'%&(-77V+!,(-^J-7-+S!
3'&'(V0! 2! (0-1N7'%&)! 70! H1-7)(6O&! (-X'&-&N! 2! 3-/0%&20!
2V%'3'32-1)B).)('2-77VW!%H0.)-1)%&'2!)! H1-&)&N!6%&-7'21077V0! K-3'7'+!
7-1',)#!
;-7^)('2-7)0!H'G1)7S!%X'('2!)!H070C!J1*!J)BB0(07.)-.))!3'1)/0%&2-!
)!%('3'2!6%16,!6201)/)&!J'W'JV!2!XOJ^0&!)!'W2-&!(V73-!+),(-7&'2#!Y-3^0!
70'XW'J)+'! Z103&('77'0! '&%10^)2-7)0! 2VH'1707)*! (0,1-+07&7VW! %('3'2!
(-K1)/7VW!H('20('3!)!'&20&'2#!
! [!3-/0%&20!H'1'^)&01N7','!H()+0(-!+'^7'!H()20%&)!-2&'+-&)K-.)O!
B)3%-.))!7-(6G07)C!dAA!)!H0(0J-/6!'B'(+107)*!G&(-B'2!'&!:[A!3!_UAAS!
/&'! 7-,1*J7'! H'3-K-1'! 3'1'%%-1N7'0! H(0)+6P0%&2'! %'2(0+077VW! .)B('2VW!
%)%&0+! 3'7&('1*! 2! J010! %7)^07)*! %+0(&7'%&)! 2! AYdS! H'H'1707)*!
,'%6J-(%&2077','!XOJ^0&-S!('%&-!J)%.)H1)7V!7-!J'(',-W!)!'J7'2(0+077'!%!
Z&)+! 6J'X%&2! J1*! H'1NK'2-&01*#! _)B('2)K-.)*! H'%&0H077'S! 7'! 2H'170!
'P6&)+'!K-+07*0&!3'((6+H)('2-77VW!3'7&('1c('2!)!2!J(6,)W!'X1-%&*W#!
!
9#E#!;)%3>'()07&)('2-77VC!H'JW'J!2!+),(-.)'77'C!H'1)&)30!
! $K! %3-K-77','! 2VG0! %10J60&S! /&'! 3()+)7'1',)/0%3)0! +0(V!
J'1^7V! H(0'X1-J-&N! %(0J)! +0(! H'! %7)^07)O! 6('27*! 70K-3'77'C! +),(-.))S!
&-3! 3-3! '7)! 7-H(*+6O! 2'KJ0C%&26O&! 7-! H()/)7V! 2'K7)37'207)*!
H(-2'7-(6G07)C!2!J-77'C!%B0(0#!d('K(-/7'%&N!)!H6X1)/7'%&N!'X0%H0/)2-O&!
H'7)+-7)0!&','S!/&'!7-!%-+'+!J010!H(')%W'J)&!2!%B0(0!+),(-.))#!!
Риск-ориентированная миграционная политика.
:),(-.)'77-*!H'1)&)3-!;I!'()07&)('2-7-!7-!X1)^-CG00!'3(6^07)0!>!
703'&'(V0!%&(-7V!XV2G0,'!MMM;S!3'&'(V0!*21*O&%*!J1*!;'%%))!)%&'/7)3'+!
(-X'/0C! %)1VS! H('J63&'2! %01N%3','! W'K*C%&2-! )! %'OK7)3-+)! 2!
H('&)2'J0C%&2))! J0%&-X)1)K-.))! H'1'^07)*! 6! O^7VW! ,(-7).! ;I#! M!
'%&-1N7V+!+)('+!0%&NS!2!16/G0+!%16/-0S!%',1-G07)*!'X!6H('P07))!2)K'2VW!
B'(+-1N7'%&0C#!
RR!
!
…n()J)/0%3)0!'%&('23)…!J1*!32-1)B).)('2-77VW!+),(-7&'2!2!;'%%))!
H(0J%&-2107V!5@@>Ib!'X!$77'2-.)'77V+!.07&(0!…M3'13'2'…!'&!58#D?#5D"DS!)!
%&-&NcC! "9#5! 'X! '%'X077'%&*W! '%6P0%&2107)*! &(6J'2'C! J0*&01N7'%&)!
)7'%&(-77V+)! ,(-^J-7-+)! >! 2V%'3'32-1)B).)('2-77V+)! %H0.)-1)%&-+)S!
220Jc77'C!2!""E>Ib!…U!H(-2'2'+!H'1'^07))###…!›!8R>Ib!'&!"?#DE#5D"D!)!0Pc!
70%3'1N3)+)!&'/0/7V+)!1N,'&-+)S!3'&'(V0!&0'(0&)/0%3)!+',6&!)%H'1NK'2-&N!
l7'!7-!J010!)%H'1NK6O&!'/07N!',(-7)/077'm!3(6H7V0!&0103'++67)3-.)'77V0!
)!=¢!3'+H-7))#!
!b-3'7'J-&01O! )! H(-2'H()+07)&01O! 76^7'! %+'&(0&N! H(-2J0! 2! ,1-K-! >!
70K-3'77V0! +),(-7&V! ,(-^J-70! F'(20,))S! r20C.-())S! ]0(+-7))S!
[01)3'X()&-7))S!MrfS!˜0W))!)!J(6,)W!%&(-7!H0(2','!+)(-!H(-3&)/0%3)!70!
2%&(0/-O&%*!2!H()('J0S!-!70K-3'77V0!+),(-7&V!)K!%&(-7!fB()3)!)!fK))S!H'!
%6&)S!'H(0J01*O&!Z&'!*2107)0#!
!o%1)!H0(2V0S!3-3!H(-2)1'S!70%6&!2!;'%%)C%36O!I0J0(-.)O!)720%&).))S!
62-^07)0! 3! K-3'76S! H()2V/36! H1-&)&N! 7-1',)S! H0(0J'2V0! &0W7'1',))!
6H(-2107)*!)!H(')K2'J%&2-S!&'!2&'(V0!2%0,'!Z&','!'XV/7'S!+*,3'!,'2'(*S!70!
70%6&#!
!F-!%0,'J7*!K-3'7!;'%%)C%3'C!I0J0(-.))!l7-H()+0(S!%&#!54!K-3'7-!""@>
Ib!…U!H'(*J30!2V0KJ-!###)!2j0KJ-###…!7-!'%7'2-7))!%&#!"8#8!Q'fd!I;m!7)3-3!70!
J)BB0(07.)(60&!J20!6H'+*76&V0!3-&0,'())!)7'%&(-77VW!,(-^J-7!lH0(2VC!)!
&(0&)C!+)(m!)!'J)7-3'2'!(-%%+-&()2-O&!%10J6OP)0!%16/-)e!!
Кейс (А)! A)(03&'(! 3(6H7','! (0,)'7-1N7','! H(0JH()*&)*S!
(-%H'1'^077','!7-!&0(()&'())!;IS!'&0.!J2')W!J0&0CS!^)26P)C!7-!J2-!J'+-!
l'J)7! )W! J'+'2! 2! %&(-70! oMmS! 20%N+-! K-+'&-77VC! H(')K2'J%&2077V+)!
2'H('%-+)S! 6H1-/)2-OP)C! X'1NG)0! %6++V! 7-1','2! 2! XOJ^0&! ;'%%)C%3'C!
I0J0(-.))S!,(-^J-7)7!oMS!7-(6G-0&!%('3!H(0XV2-7)*!H'!%2'0C!+7','10&70C!
)!6^0!70'J7'3(-&7'!H('J1c77'C!(-X'/0C!2)KV
R4!
!
Кейс (Б)! ](-^J-7)7! -B()3-7%3'C! %&(-7VS! 2j0W-2G)C! 2! ;I! H'!
%&6J07/0%3'C! 2)K0S! ^)26P)C! 2! :'%320! %! 6^0! X'100! "D! 10&! %! J-27'!
H('%('/077'C! 2)K'C! X0K! 3-3)W>1)X'! 10,-1N7VW! J'36+07&'2! )! 70! H1-&*P)C!
7)3-3)W!7-1','2#!
[! 'X')W! %16/-*W! %-73.)0C! X6J0&! +7','10&7)C! K-H(0&! 7-! 2j0KJ! 2!
;'%%)C%36O!I0J0(-.)OS!)!%'&(6J7)3)!UL[:!:[AS!3-3!)!%6JN*!70!H(0+)76&!
K-*2)&N! '! &'+S! /&'! `K-3'7! J1*! 2%0W! 0J)7a#! [! (0-1N7'%&)! K-3'7! X6J0&! X'100!
+*,'3! 3! ,(-^J-7)76! )K! %16/-*! lkmS! &-3! 3-3! '7! H('%&'! '%&-70&%*! 2! :'%320! )!
H('J'1^)&! %2'O! J0*&01N7'%&NS! &',J-! 3-3! H()2V3G)C! %'X1OJ-&N! (-K1)/7V0!
K-3'7V!,(-^J-7)7!oM! 20(7c&%*!J'+'C!3!%6H(6,0!)!J0&*+!)!X'100!70!%+'^0&!
2j0K^-&N! 2! ;IS! ,J0! '^)J-0+'! H'&0(*0&! (-X'&6S! &'! 0%&N! X6J0&! 7-(6G07-!
Z3'7'+)/0%3-*! J0*&01N7'%&N! H(0JH()*&)*S! 2! (0K61N&-&0! /0,'! %'3(-&*&%*!
7-1','2V0! '&/)%107)*S! -! )+)J^! ;'%%))! 3-3! %&(-7VS! 70J(6^01OX7'C! 3!
+),(-7&-+S! H'J3(0H)&N%*! 0Pc! 'J7'C! %0()0C! )%&'()CS! (-%%3-KV2-0+VW! H'!
%-(-B-77'+6!(-J)'!)K!6%&!2!6%&-!+7',)+!J0%*&3-+!1OJ0C#!
A)BB0(07.)('2-77VC! H'JW'J! 3! +),(-.)'77'C! H'1)&)30! &-3^0!
70'XW'J)+!)!2!H0()'JV!+-%G&-X7VW!%H'(&)27VW!+0('H()*&)CS!&-3)W!3-3!˜:>
5D"8S! 3',J-! X0K! 3-3'C>1)X'! +),(-.)'77'C! B)1N&(-.))! 2! ;'%%))! l2! :'%320m!
'%&-1)%N!70%3'1N3'!&V%*/
5D
!70K-3'77VW!+),(-7&'2S!,1-27V+!'X(-K'+!)K!%&(-7!
fB()3)#!
A-77V0! 'X%&'*&01N%&2-! J'1^7V! H()7)+-&N%*! 2'! 27)+-7)0! )! 2!
X-(N0(7VW! +0(-WS! )! 2! +0(-WS! H()K2-77VW! %&)+61)('2-&N! )++),(-7&'2S!
3'&'(VW! ,'%6J-(%&2'! %/)&-0&! ^01-&01N7V+)#! ;'%%))! 76^7'! H0(0W'J)&N! '&!
B'(+V! 3! %6&)#! M'&(6J7)3)! :[A! )! :$AS! H()7)+-OP)0! 6/-%&)0! 2!
)++),(-.)'77VW! 'B'(+107)*WS! J'1^7V! 7-6/)&N%*! H('2'J)&N! (-K2c(76&V0!
)7&0(2NO! )! H()7)+-&N! (0G07)*! H'! 3'73(0&7V+! 30C%-+! 7-! '%7'20! %)%&0+! %!
!
5D
!•€€y}e••zœ#•„•898"D9•5D"?>D">5E•—>v—‰>|x}••z€xŠz>€™}zx••z>|{Š{’xŠ|u>u}€x—}•z‘•}zx>’u}€{z>
••v>5D"8!
R8!
!
)%H'1NK'2-7)0+! )%36%%&2077','! )7&01103&-S! 3-3! Z&'! J01-0&%*S! 7-H()+0(S! 2!
Mrf!)!Q-7-J0
5"
#!
!
!
! !
!
5"
•€€y}e••vx’xœz|{#„€u•u|€u#•x•y{uyŠ{•xŠ„v|z>‰u|u•}••uvy„€{•>}x™}>|u>y{€•x>vuŠ|x•>xz>
zvvz’•x€zu|>‰{•z}zu|}•!
R?!
!
Заключение!
!
!˜)%1'!7010,-1N7VW!+),(-7&'2!H'!'.073-+!:[A!;I!%'%&-21*0&!'&!5!J'!
5SE! +17
55
#! d'! '.073-+! )%%10J'2-&010CS! (-%H'1-,-OP)W! J'%&6H'+! 3!
20J'+%&2077'C!%&-&)%&)30S!H(0%&6H7'%&N!2!%B0(0!+),(-.))!)+00&!`1-&07&7VC!
W-(-3&0(a#!A(6,)+)!%1'2-+)S!,'%6J-(%&2'!70!(-%H'1-,-0&!&'/7V+)!J-77V+)!
'X! )W! 3'1)/0%&20#! d('%&'0! %(-2707)0! 3'1)/0%&2-! H(),'2'('2! %6J'2! H'!
+),(-.)'77V+!%&-&N*+S!H()20Jc77'0!2VG0!l'&!J0%*&3'2!J'!%'&07!H(),'2'('2!
2! ,'Jm! H'3-KV2-0&S! /&'! Z&'! 3'1)/0%&2'! 70! H(02VG-0&! DS5E•! '&! '.07'/7','!
3'1)/0%&2-! 70K-3'77VW! +),(-7&'2S! 7-W'J*P)W%*! 7-! &0(()&'())! ;'%%)C%3'C!
I0J0(-.))#! Y'! 0%&N! 1)GN! DS5E•! H(0%&6H107)C! H'16/-O&! 3-36O>1)X'!
%6J0X76O! '.0736#! F'! Z&'! J-103'! 70! H'17-*! 3-(&)7-#! UXP00! 3'1)/0%&2'!
)7'%&(-77VW! ,(-^J-7S! 7-W'J*P)W%*! 7-! &0(()&'())! ;'%%))S! '.07)2-0&%*!
H()+0(7'! 2! "D! +17! /01'203#! ˜-%&N! )K! 7)W! 7-W'J*&%*! 7-! &0(()&'())! ;I!
B'(+-1N7'!K-3'77'S!7'!7-(6G-O&!&0!)1)!)7V0!&(0X'2-7)*!K-3'7'J-&01N%&2-S!
7-H()+0(S!H(-2)1-!+),(-.)'77','!6/c&-S!2)K'2V0!H(-2)1-!)1)!%''&20&%&2)0!
K-*21077'C! )! B-3&)/0%3'C! .010C! H(0XV2-7)*#! \&)! 7-(6G07)*S! 2! %)16!
)+0OP)W%*! 3()+)7'1',)/0%3)W! 'X%&'*&01N%&2S! 7'%*&! +-%%'2VC! W-(-3&0(#!
Y-3)+! 'X(-K'+! '/02)J7-! 70%H'%'X7'%&N! ,'%6J-(%&2-! ZBB03&)27'!
3'7&('1)('2-&N!+),(-.)'776O!%B0(6!%6P0%&26OP)+)!+0&'J-+)#!o%1)!/0,'>
&'!)!76^7'!J'X)2-&N%*!2!Z&'C!'X1-%&)!&-3!Z&'!)%H'17*0+'%&)!)!%'X1OJ07)*!
6^0!6%&-7'21077VW!7'(+!K-3'7-#!
!r-,)! H'! 6201)/07)O! /)%1-! )! (-K7''X(-K)*! 6,'1'27'>H(-2'2VW! +0(!
X6J6&!7-/)7-&N%*!)!K-3-7/)2-&N%*!7-!H(-3&)30!70%3'1N3)+)!J0%*&3-+)!1)X'!
70%3'1N3)+)!%'&7*+)!6,'1'27VW!J01!2!,'J!2!B0J0(-1N7'+!+-%G&-X0#!A(6,)+)!
%1'2-+)S!H('X10+-!70! +'^0&!XV&N!ZBB03&)27'! (0G07-! 6,'1'27'>H(-2'2V+)!
+0&'J-+)#!!
!
55
•€€y}e•••’#•„•5D"8•"5•5"•—>v—‰>|xœ—xŠz>••z}Šu>|{Š{’xŠ|™•>vz’•x|€u—>—>•u}}zz#•€vŠ!
!
4D!
!
;0G07)0! 10^)&! 2! H1'%3'%&)! 3()+)7'1',)/0%3)W! +0(#! Q()+)7'1',)*!
)K6/-0&!H()/)7V!)!6%1'2)*!2'K7)37'207)*!H(0%&6H7'%&)S!H6&)!)!%(0J%&2-!0c!
H(0J6H(0^J07)*#! Q()+)7'1',)/0%3)0! +0(VS! H(0J%&-21*O&! %'X'C! 6+01'0!
)%H'1NK'2-7)0! 6^0! %6P0%&26OP)W! %'.)-1N7'>J0+',(-B)/0%3)W! H('.0%%'2S!
20J6P)W! 3! %'3(-P07)O! H(0%&6H7'%&)#! [! J-77'+! %16/-0! Z&'! +0(V! H'!
2V20J07)O! )K! &07)! &(6J'2'C! +),(-.))S! 0c! 231O/07)*! 2! 7-1','2VC! 'X'('&#!
d0(%H03&)2V! Z&','! H'JW'J-! H'3-! 70! 'H(0J0107VS! &-3! 3-3! %'2(0+077'0!
H'1)&)/0%3'0! (63'2'J%&2'! ;'%%)C%3'C! I0J0(-.))! K-7)+-0&%*! )! X6J0&!
H('J'1^-&N! K-7)+-&N%*! %'W(-707)0+! }€x€„}! ¦„u! )! 63(0H107)0+! %)1'2'C!
%'%&-21*OP0C!,'%6J-(%&2077'C!%)%&0+VS!3-3!'7'!0c!H'7)+-0&#!
˜&'!70!&-3!%!:[A!;I¡!
Y()!'%7'27V0!H('X10+V#!
!d0(2-*! H('X10+-! i! '&/c&7'%&N#! :[A! ;I! H0(0,(6^07'! %'KJ-7)0+!
276&(0770C! '&/c&7'%&)#! U,('+7V0! 1OJ%3)0! )! 2(0+077V0! (0%6(%V!
(-%W'J6O&%*! 7-! %'KJ-7)0! &(0X60+'C! 3-(&)7VS! 7-! '&H)%3)! )! '&3-KV! 2!
2'KX6^J07))! 6,'1'27VW! J01S! 3'&'(V0! %'&(6J7)3-+! :[A! 70! 2V,'J7'!
(-%%10J'2-&N!%!&'/3)!K(07)*!'&/c&7'%&)#!:7',)0!J01-!(-%%10J6O&%*!H'!1',)30!
`H(0%10J60+!&','S!3','!2)J700!)!10,/0!H(0%10J'2-&Na#!\&-!&07J07.)*!W'('G'!
'&(-^07-S!7-H()+0(S!2!%6J0X7'C!%&-&)%&)30!H()+0707)*!%&-&N)!LQ!;I!955#9#!
![&'(-*!H('X10+-!i!3-J(V#!U%&(VC!J0B).)&!3'+H0&07&7VW!%'&(6J7)3'2S!
K-7)+-OP)W%*!(0-1N7V+!J01'+#!:7',)0!H(0%&6H107)*!2!:[A!(-%%10J'2-&N!
H('%&'! 70! 6%H02-O&! )1)! 70! 6+0O&#! UX! Z&'+! %2)J0&01N%&260&! &'&! B-3&S! /&'!
H'J-21*OP00! X'1NG)7%&2'! %&-&0C! LQ! ;I! )%H'1NK6O&%*! 3(-C70! (0J3'#! d'!
703'&'(V+!Z+H)()/0%3)+!'.073-+
59
!"D•!H0(%'7-1-!'(,-7)K-.))!J01-O&!ED•!
H'10K7'C!(-X'&V! Z&'C!'(,-7)K-.))#![! %16/-0!%!:[A!;I
5@
!Z&'! 'K7-/-0&S!/&'!
H'1'2)76!H'10K7'C! (-X'&V!J01-O&!70! X'100!8D! &V%*/!%'&(6J7)3'2! )K!X'100!
/0+!8DD!&V%*/#!
!
59
•€€y}e••{|#Œz‘zy{‰zx#u•’•Œz‘z•‚{•{‘“¬#“‰{“wuŠŠx“Ÿ•z•{!
5@
•€€y}e•••„#Œz‘zy{‰zx#u•’•Œz‘z•:)7)%&0(%&2'“276&(077)W“J01“;'%%)C%3'C“I0J0(-.))!