D#+E& '#!C! !'00-;$)(J#$8!&
D+!(" & #*.! .!!E&%D( !' ,'!#1GU(D(B DV7!
9
.#%$' &%B! ' !' " .!' (" & D $#*.&D$
&& # !1& DL!!#)%#$ '%*B ! *!F !7 !
&&F ')#D!7)+D(#!$ &#H . ,.!!E7#*.!+,
&%##$E'!#1G7'& 7B !G&&%"#%$'
&! ,)#F! (!#* &D E#E+E&%.DL!!#)%#$J
&%. & ' #!C! !' -3--= $ )( %D(+E ' !
(#!$ &# #1 #*.! ! .!!E & %D( !' DB!&! , #. !!E
U(D(B DV " .$#% &%##$$ '!# &7 ! ! &&F ,
)#D! '!*.% &)E '%*B % *!F %
-
D'% *! & G
#!$ &#H #*.! '1B D7 #*.!$ &%##$E '!#1G7
<!#!'%CD &D ' .!' 8 "#! 8 $ &D+ )+
D(!F!.E"#!P'%*B ! *!F !7!GF '&&%"#%$'
C1"&!'!C!1&& %H G&D&D$$#.&D$&%. '
%.&1.) 1&(" & &!)DB!&!#. !!E#!)!D
0
# J'&&#+&%.!)+ "#!."# +DD !L )""+D
)# 1&)! ' !7BD(C E#!$ &#H #$8
"# $# # %D( ! "%D 0 & 33 & ,#+ (.#1
('*&1%B& .$#!. DE*!F +B !'7B.D ,
&%B!!),. '. 1!&!&1.#$8K)(1 ,
D'"!& #17 L"!#+,7 #&,.+ &# .$# &%##$$
'!# &7D#+! "!& &( &)#F! !'&%.7 7L#+,7
)(1 D'"!& #1 '#1+E #!.7 "# B !+E &%)R!D'
1
!C! !!F&D$#E$&%.$&D+00-;$"$#*.&D'%
.!%S-L-T-;TT#, !F&D$#E$&%.$&D+
2
!C! ! (!#* &D$ #E$ &%. DL!!#)%#$ -3--= $ "
$#*.&D'%.!%S-L0=T-=Z[!D#+E#!&%#&\TT%.!)+!#!C! !* '
.&%"K&%.!)+!#!C! #IT223=00Tjo^jkqjqO.)#F! K2-=$Q
3
"!H !"#!.!! !&D&D$$#.&D$&%.;/-$"
$#*.&D'%.!%S00L-/;=TZ[!D#+E#!&%#&\TT#!* '.&%"K
]^^_KTTeb`jnbabk^agT20-0TO.)#F! K03-=$Q
91
C! E"&%##$'%'!# &%&!.& !!"#'!#$D(
$&%.#&!E#!$ &#H #*.! #!)!D
)F ' +.' )!&!& G&&!.%GF !K
( ! &"! ! & , )(!1& &#+ .$#
&%##$$ '!# & '$% )+1 "# !B!+ D !&!&
&!& & )F ' "# ' $#*.&D$ (D.!1&7 &
%B!'&"!H I D C! E"&%##$'%'!# &%M
.%$7B(D.!1&!&"!H 1+!"*! )
!&!& &# D$ .$# &%&%G7 "#D D! !$
%B& D BF!&!$"# !DG&1DD.$#E!&!& M
!),. '!& #'+7D&GF !&!&!&
&#.$#&%##$$'!# &M
H!, (F + !#!& &%)R!D ( #%!'$ .$#7
&B !'7B&!.%!"#!.%&'#!1!&!&1#$8
(D(#!$ &#H #. !1&D ,&%)R!D
92
ЗАКЛЮЧЕНИЕ
&,. ( $7 B &%##$! '!# & !& . ' (
'!. 7 '* (DGB 17 B !$ H!1G !& "#!.! !
)!&". &&!. ! & % &%##$$ '!# & "(
&.!1&!.%GF !+.+K
Q !&%##$$'!# &7"# !.!!"=&33&
,#+ (.#17 '$' &".! & !' !#' ' 7 D#+!
&.!#*&#' +, &B D, &#+,$&%.#&.D# !
I#'% #%G& ".)+! "#!.!! 7 "J'% '+ &B !'7 B "#
B !$1$ !#' ! !),. '& D&#% #1 +!
.!I H '!&!&!'7&%F!&!+'!.&D'%D($"
!& 7 B ! ,+! ".$ !1+E J" #! (H
"#$#''+&%##$$'!# &7 J"#)!.*!)+1&"!
-Q H!, .!*F!E #!$'!H C! E " &%##$'%
'!# &%!),. 'DGB 1.!1%G$%7"&F!%G
.$#% &%##$$ '!# &7 $.! )%.% "!#!B &!+ .!1+,
&1, &%F!&!+! %& J$ .$#7 "# '!#+E "!#!B!1
." !1+,%& E7"# )(& &#.$# .#D*!
&!.%!"#!.%&'#!1# 1%.&!#!%GI#'%D$.$#7
B )!&"!B ." !1+E D#1 & &#+ $&%.#& H!
# %&7D#+E%.&!# .$#1D"&!$7DD"#!# !$
&!& !(D% !#!&'&#H!, )1C!E$#
"# )%.%F!$ #!)!D . !$ (DGB! 7 C ($.7 .
"#!.%&'#!1"%B! !#(#!C! #$"!D ""!B !1&
0Q #! #!$% # ! &%##$$ '!# & (#%)!*+,
&#, '!! &G &"!H I D% B&1 "*! E7 &.!#*F ,&
&#' (D.!1&!7 "$!'7 "! '* DGB 1
#&& E&D ! &B D 7 B"( ".1 #!$% # ! &%##$$
'!# & C!E &#! )!! +&D E "#E %#!1
93
B&& 7 "#! '* "#!.%&'#!1K )(!1&1 (DGB!
.#!'! & .$#' &%##$$ '!# & .$# &
'!. H &DE#$ (H !E7$.!)%.!"# &,. 1#! (H "#$#''+
&%##$$ '!# & O ) (DGB1 #!,&# E .$#QM
('*&1 %B& &(. J')# DD '$7 D
! '$.#) '!# M."%& '&1(DGB! .$#
&%##$' '!# &! 1D . ' ( &%"#%$7 & " &1'!$
&$& .#%$$ &%"#%$M %&! ! )!! &#$ , #!) E D
D. .%#!&%##$E'!# .#
2Q H!,% I DH #'&%##$''!# &!7.!E&%GF ,
#(+,&#,7"#!.&!&7B&& . H #1(DGB! !
'!*.%#.$.$#.!E&%GF !.$#+"#E
"'F !& &!.%GF ! ."! K DGB 1 , D ( +!
#'+)"#!.!! "#7"# '! '$DC! '"&%##$'%
'!# &%7&*!+' &#+'J!'!'M!& '!# 1+!
#'+ "# ( .$# GF!'& $&%.#&! "&!.& E
(DGB! &"! .$# &%##$$ '!# &
!## #
3Q (D.!1&! &%&%! "#!.!! ! .$#
&%##$$ '!# & J'%"#!.$!& "#!.%&'#!1
&!.%GF!!" !D$.$#KJ&$C! !&%"#%$ +, H7
"#!.%&'#!+,(D'7&.E&#+7 &%##$E'!# 7&.#%$E
&#+7 &!& & D#+' &%##$%G '1 ($!&
)(&1"#,*.! "#!.# !1$'!. H &D$)&!.
"&!.%GF!$"#!.! '!. H &DE"#H!.%#+ '"H J')#
!!#$ (' H!,+C #*.! #!)!D7.#%$ &#
)(%!&)!&"!B 1%& 7!),. '+!..!*F!$ &"!
&%##$E'!#1G%D(E)(&
Q &,. ( ( &%.!)E "#D D .D# 1+, +.7
"$!'7B.$#&%##$$'!# &!&!" '!+'
94
$#*.&DL"#+'&$C! !'7(DGB!'+'& #'&&
2- 2-MJ&'!C+E.$#7"J'%D!'%"# '!G&
#'+).!1+, .,$#*.&DL"#+,.$#O&&)G.! !'
"# &1 2 Q7 !.&GF!E B& L )F ! "# H "+
#!$% # $#*.&DL"#+, C! E O"# H "+ #(%'& 7
.)#&!&& .#Q ( #%!'+E.$#!&D&!&%1+'7
& $' B!&D '7 !#+'7 &#B+' )+B P ('!(.+'M
& &#$ B+E,#D!#
/Q #)!' (D.!1&! !& &%& ! %D(
)(B! !U(D(B DV ( #%!''.$#!C!'%'! G7
,&!.%!%D(+1DDU"!H 1+,#. !!EV7&%##$%G'1
DDU$!&H $ &" !V'&%)R!D+E&&.$#D*!
#!)%!&!.%GF!ED##!D #D K
LC! '%*B + *!F +7!&&F ,)#D!7&!.%!
.) 1I#(%KU'!*.%&)E &.#%$ ' H' VM
L && U"!H 1+, #. !!EV .*! )+1 ."!
"&#!.&'DGB! !$. D ,'%*B H7).GF ,"#'
#&"#*! !D# D&!# #+' ) '!# '
;Q &+' &%F!&!+' %& !' .$# &%##$$
'!# & !& "#!.'! .$#7 D#+E7 C ($.7 '*
)(B 1&!.%GF ')#('KJ.!E& %B& DJ$.$#7
&(+! & '"H !E J')# #$ (' &%##$E '!# 7
+C !' #*.! !' !G #!)!D O('* )!! D#D!
)(B! ! "#!.'! .$#K .!E& " #! (H "#$#''+
&%##$$ '!# &Q +' &%F!&!+' %& ' G&
%D( K D B!& J')# 7 D#+! )%.% "!#!!&!+ 'D%
&%##$E'!# O&%B! !'7B1 ) '!# + &"1(%G&"# ,
&(. QM '!. H &D%G #$ (H G7 GF%G& &" !!'
"#$#''+ &%##$$ '!# &M '!& "#* &%##$E
'!# "!# .+C #!)!DO.!!EQM&#D 7!B! !D#+,
95
.*!)+1#! (D*.+EJ""#$#''+&%##$$'!# &
DB!&!." !1+,%& E.$#'*DGB 1%& )
)(& &%##$E'!# &)G.1&!'!. H &D !"#!." &
B +1& ) J' "!#!. U(D(B D' VM #('!#! ($#*.! 7
+"B !'$ U(D(B D' V &%##$E '!# O!& .$# !
!& )!(('!(.+'QM "#.D! ('!F! #&,. &%##$E
'!# .#%$ !
=Q !#!&, )%.%F!$ #!)!D !),. ' DGB 1
%D( ! 7 B .$# &%##$$ '!# & '* "# (1
!(DGB!+' .% &%& DD$L ) &%F!&!$ %&
1D. '"H J')# #$ ('&%##$E'!#
Q &"! ! .$# &%##$$ '!# & &%F!&!&
" )F ' "# ' $#*.&D$ (D.!1& ) &"!
)(!1& # J' .$#+! )(!1&7 "#!.%&'#!+!
&$C! !'  D*! .*+ &"1& # ( D!
)&!1&7 GF ,&%)R!D+E&&D$.$#O"# '!#7
D$. &%"#%$ #(! &1 . ( , %'!#Q7 .!E& ! .$#
"#.*!&7 !$ &"! ! &%F!&!& )F , & ,
O"# '!#7 "!#!* C ' &%"#%$'Q B !'7 B D( &"!
.$#."%&D!&"# B %& E7"#!.%&'#!+, &&23L23
Q "#D D! '*!& "#)!' ( D! &%B,7 D$.
&(. J')# &"1(%G&D# D&!# #+!) '!# +
H!, ,#(#!C! ' "#!.$!&&!.%GF!!K
L H' 7%"#'B!+' #&"#*! !D ' ) '!# '
&!.%!&B 1"!#!* C!$&%"#%$7#. !!E &!#C!! ,.!!E
%'!#C!$ H7 7&!&!7 .*+)+1.!!+"#'
(DGB! !.$#&%##$$'!# &M
L "# !&! D%G (" &1 #*.! #!)!D &!.! E
#. !,&!.%!#&"#&# 1"#!(%'"H GH&7"#!.%&'#!%G
96
" - & 2; 7 %'!#C!$ $!! B!&D$ #. ! #!)!D O!
( & '& !$ "Q7 D#+' "# * ( )+ &.+
D# D&!#H G) '!# +7 &"1(+!.&(. J')#
-Q # !&! &!.! E #. !, #!)!D7 #*.!$
&%##$E'!#1G7&B !'H!!&)#(+'"# '!1"*!
.)#1' "# ( H& '!# & H'7 !
GF '&&#E.$#&%##$$'!# &
0Q ()(H-"2&37C($.7. &DGB 1
#!) !"%B! &$& &%##$E'!# (" &1U(D(B DV
DB!&! #. !!E #*.!$ !G #!)!D7 B )%.! &!&1
!#!&'#!)!D !$$!! B!&D ,#. !!E
2Q !&!&1".$#%&%##$$'!# &&%"!
)F , & ,7 "#D D! BF! "# '!!& .$#
!&!&1 & !&!& '!#+7 "# '!!'+! D
+' %B& D' .$# &%##$$ '!# &7 ! .*+
#%C1 #!) & 2 7 !&1 ! "# #!B 1 &%F!&%
&!'!E+,C! E
3Q $!'7 B !),. ' DGB 1 #'%
D'"!&H '#1$ #!.7 "# B !$ %B& D% .$#
&%##$$'!# &! &"! !' !.!*F ' &"! !'
)(!1&.#%$ '%B& D'
#(#!C! %D(+, +,"#)!'7&(+,&&%##$+'
'!# &'7 "!#%G B!#!.1 ( & )!&"!B! ! "# !#!&
#!)!D7 D#+E " & &! )$.# '!.% &%##$$
'!# &
97
СПИСОК ИСПОЛЬЗОВАННЫХ ИСТОЧНИКОВ И ЛИТЕРАТУРЫ
1. Международные договоры и иные документы:
!H (F !"#B!!D &+,&).O$ '7
2=3$M& ('03-2$QTT4G!!1'!*.%#.+,.$#
-S0
- 4#G&&!1&D .!D#H &!' #E '!. H &DE &&H H
=;3 $ TT &!&!+! "# B!!DK )# D '!# !' #
&D&DE?!1& D&DE$#%""+U#B!!DV+"-T.#!.5
4$#(7-0;;
0 !H "#,#!)!DO.)#!!!#1E&&')!!E
-=;= $Q TT )# D '!*.%#.+, .$# ==0
+"%&D“u„X
2 ?# #"!E&D$G()&+,"#,O-/T00TQ
O$ #&)%#$7 ---/ $Q Z[!D#+E #!&%#&\ TT ?# #%&&D'
(+D!".$!."%) DH & &!',&%1G&!* '
.&%"K]^^_KTTtttsdk`gi^bk^agTO.)#F! K-3-=$Q
3 .!1+E(D"# .!E& #$!G.1' O#
$DL!!#)%#$!02-;$&! !'0L0L'"!#'
(&!. !*"#'!&DE &&')! $&%.#&L%B& D Q TT
I#'H +E )G!!1 !*"#'!&D &&')! $&%.#&L
%B& D.#%*!&!( & '+,&%.#&-;S2-0L030
.!1+E (D ) ,#! #!"#.%D +, "#
#!"#.%D $(.#1$#*.O# $DL!!#)%#$!-;-2
$&! !'2L-2L'"!#'(&!. !*"#'!&DE
&&')! $&%.#&L%B& DQZ[!D#+E#!&%#&\TTD%'!
"%) D ! )+ &%1G& !* ' .&%"K
]^^_KTTtttsdk`gi^bk^agTO.)#F! K23-=$Q
98
2. Нормативные акты и законопроекты РФ:
- & %H && E&DE!.!#H --==0$O&%B!'
""#D7 !&!+, 8D' && E&DE !.!#H ""#D, D
& %H && E&DE!.!#H 0--;$SL870--;
$ S /L87 3--2 $ S -L87 -/-2 $ S L8Q TT
)# !(D.!1&-2S020=;
-- "#!.!! ! & %H $ %. -/=-; $ S
-0;L Z[!D#+E #!&%#&\ TT D%'! "%) D ! )+
&%1G&!* '.&%"K]^^_KTTtttsdk`gi^bk^agTO.)#F! K
--=$Q
-0 #*.&D E D.!D& && E&DE !.!#H OB&1 "!#Q
0==2$S3L8O#!.0;-;$M& (';0-=$QTT
)# !(D.!1&==2S0-00
-2 !'!E+ED.!D&&& E&DE!.!#H -=-==3$S--0L
8O#!.-=3-=$QTT)# !(D.!1&==S
-3 $+ED.!D&&& E&DE!.!#H 0==$S0L
8O#!.-/--;$QTT)# !(D.!1&==S-3
-=32
- #*.&D E D.!D& && E&DE !.!#H OB&1 #!1Q
--$S2L8O#!.0;-;$M& (';0-=$QTT
)# !(D.!1&-S2=233-
-/ !.!#1+E (D 3==/ $ S 20L8 U) D,
$#*.&D$ && V O #!. -=3-= $Q TT )# !
(D.!1&==/S2/302
-; !.!#1+E (D -- $ S 0-0L8 U) &,
,#+(.#1$#*.&& E&DE!.!#H VO#!.-=3-=$QTT
)# !(D.!1&-S2;/-2
-= 8D DL!!#)%#$ =--; $ U !## # 1E
"#$#''! $&%.#&!+, $# E )!&"$ D( $#*.'
99
'!. H &DE"'F DL!!#)%#$!-=$. "+E"!# .
-- -- $.V Z[!D#+E #!&%#&\ TT I H 1+E &E
.' &#H DL!!#)%#$ !* ' .&%"K
tttndc`_eagTkdar†ebfbTk_bO.)#F! K-;3-=$Q
- &! ! -2-/ $ S 2-L/ U
"#!D! I!.!#1$ (D | //-3-L U !&! ('!! E
!'!E+ED.!D&&& E&DE!.!#H &1G!.!#1$(D
U)D,$#*.&D$&& VB& "# '!! &"'$!1+,
#!"#.%D +,!,$ EVTT)# !(D.!1&-/S;
-/-
- &! ! -3-; $ S 30L/ U
"#!D! I!.!#1$ (D S 003=L/ U !&! ('!! E
.!1+! (D.!1+! D+ && E&DE !.!#H B& ("#!
&%##$$'!# &VVTT)# !(D.!1&-;S23
=-
-- # D( (.#&& 0;--$S/U"#.D!
&"1( &"'$!1+, #!"#.%D +, !,$ E7
"# "D( , $# B! ,D ,"# '!! GVO#!.--;
$M(#!$ &# # G&!&& ---0$S-/QTT&& E&D
$(!"!H+"%&D-0"#!S/;T
-0 &"#*! ! ' ! " (.#,#! G # !1&
DL!!#)%#$ ---/ $ S 3L# U) #$ (H D(
&"!H ( #E '!. H &DE "'F "# !B! )!&". &
"# '!! !' &"'$!1+, #!"#.%D +, !,$ E #'D,
!## # 1E "#$#''+ $&%.#&!+, $# E )!&"$
D( $#*.' '!. H &DE "'F DL!!#)%#$!V
Z[!D#+E #!&%#&\ TT D%'! "%) D ! )+
&%1G&!* '.&%"K]^^_KTTtttsdk`gi^bk^agTO.)#F! K
-33-=$Q
100