$!'7 B "#&, &%& J')# 7 !$ &(.
&"1( P B&& 7 "# #!$% # C! E "
&%##$'% '!# &%7 L . # ! #1& "( H <
"# '!#7&!'&! 2-/$"!%U[&Oƒcbk`Q
"# !. !$#!&VO*)S00=T3Q
7(F F !#!&+
)+C!E*!+7<"#.!'&# #D%G"( H GKU& '%*B
)!#D' B!D !$&"!#'7&,#!."#!.! , #%#$ B!&D$
'!C!1&7&.!C!$!$!)# ')!&".+'7)+ &"1(
.&(. '!&!&!$"#!#'J')# !& "##&"&1.
'"H J')# &%##$E '!# 7 D ! '*!
&"#!"&1'!# D(!"#.*! "#H!.%#+ "'!F!
!!J')# V& *!&%##$'1"*!!&1&%B& D'
.$#&%##$$'!# &7 )+C*!!( & '&
&$& !&$& )+C!$'%*D*!'*!"#.* 1%B& !
J'.$#!
C!'% "#!."*! G7 D B!& .$# &%##$$
'!# &&& &D*.+'$.')%.!(#&1)#F! !D
&(&'$ ' ID#' LDD&%)R!D +' 7D )R!D +' K
L"&!.& ' D(+!'EU.!'$#I B!&DE'+V=L,$.
??!DM
L!$ +' ! ' )F!&!7"#'%G&D(+GF ' &
.!#.+, I%DH , B!!D D7 (&!. )!( -;2-/ $
#!( .!'% +')+(%B!"%$GF& & DKW
%! B &1B &!&!#C!! ,#D'
-
M
L %,%.C! !'JD$ B!&DE)&D 7B7)!(%&7 !
&"&)&1D.!#*.! G7 .#
O.)#F! K-3-=$Q
1
&! ! < 2-/ $ " !% U[& Oƒcbk`Q "#
!. !$ #!&V O*) S 00=T3Q TT 4G!!1 #"!E&D$ %. "
"#'B!!D-/S
2
% D& ##&B &!&!#C!! ,#D'W
Z[!D#+E#!&%#&\TTK I#'H !$!&&& KI H 1+E&E
!* '.&%"K]^^_KTT^b``agTde`s]j`^cdT2--20O.)#F! K--=$Q
81
J'%".%&!#C!&"#!. +&[5!C 5
EK U#. H +&#! &!'1 %*! ! '*! )!&"!B 1
&"# (.&#.!1D%*$#&& E&D'%J&%DB!&7
D B!&V
J'%&&! .!'$#I B!&DE&) 1&
&& 7 .%'!&7 )1C%G "'F1 D*! #' ! "#D B!&D!
#( !&%##$$'!# &
2.2. Ответственность по договору суррогатного материнства в связи с
неисполнением обязательств
B ! (DGB! 7 &"! &.!#* .$#
&%##$$'!# &7D#+!,)+' '1#!$'! #+
(D.!1&'7 C! !&!& %B& D D$
&$C! "#!)F!&%&%GDD !L )&"!H 1+!#'+
& .$#! "' ' U(D(B DV &%##$E '!# D*!
%B&%! '!. H &D#$ (H 7#! (%GF"#$#''%&%##$$
'!# &7'! '7BJ#$ (H T !!#) D '$%)+1
"# !B!+ D $#*.&DL"#E7 .' &# E7 . &H " #E
T %$E !&!& ! .! ( #% & "#.D
"# !B! D!&!& %D(+, H7DDDJ+,. (#'D
. &&!#H $ &&!. 7 '! ' C1 7 B
#!$'! #+&!&%GF '#&!+'(D.!1&'
#)!'+7&(+!&!&!&1G"!H 1+,%B& D
.$# &%##$$ '!# &7 '$% ( D%1 (.$ .
(DGB! .$#!.%!".B!#D%1KDD"# 7( DGF !"#
J' &"#+ BF! &!$ ".".G ". .!E& ! #' ! &!'!E$
$#*.&D$"#7".#' +!"*! .#%$ ,#&!E"#
7&!&!7.! %B& DD ,& %H ED I H #%G&!
1
5!C [75!#&#* '&1)#DDDD%1%#)#(%GF E
"# H ")#B$"#K+)#&& #%)!*!“X“L““!DTT&# $&%.#&
"#-2S--
82
DB!&! $#*.&DL"#$ &!'!EL"#$"##%C! 7
B!#.!'&# #%!'&D(!"# '!#!)#F! "!H 1$
U(D(B DV".$#%&%##$$'!# &DD(+!'EU*!L
&%#''!V!SL;-T-)+#&&'#!---$ $. &D '
#E+'&%.'$< +8)ED1&D$D#K$#LD9) &1
&!#C! "#!&%"! 7"#!.%&'#!$B&1G-&
%.
%& &!.%GF !)&!1&K) !''!-3$#('!&
!#!!)R! !"#!.&! %&%$ &%##$E'!# J
)R! ! D D%&1 $#LD 57 &(C &1 & ) !'E B!#!(
') 1! "# *! ! U„lejaV @!F + %& )&%. "#&+
)%.%F!$ .$# &%##$$ '!# & $#LD 5 "!#!B &
9 .!!*+! &#!.& . "#,*.! ) !'E '!. H &D$
)&!. .D ) !' J "# C1 B&1 &#!.&7
"%B!+,$#LD 57&1%G&%''%"# & &!)! $!$#L
D 9 )+ "# ( E &!#C! D# ' #%!'$ !E
"#!&%"!
-
!B*!7D& %H '$)+!( D%17!& )+
%B& H+ " &$ U'!#"# V . "!#!.B .!!$ (DGB
" &1'!+E.$#&%##$$'!# &
.%&%& "*! E(D)!&!& 7C! ,
&%##$$'!# &'*$# 1"#! '%F!&!.$#E
!&!& !&1%B& D .$#&%##$$'!# &DD
& 7 D '!#+ !&!& '$% "#!.%&'#!1 &''
.$#! DGB! ! &$C! ! "*! E .$#E
!&!& !(B! &DGB! "# '!! )F ,"*! E
$#*.&DL"#E!&!& &! (&%.!)E"#D D
'+"# C D(DGB! G7B"# &%& #' $(D#!"!
"# ) !&!& &%.' ! &!$. %B +G& ID B!&D
1
$+ED.!D&&& E&DE!.!#H 0==$S0L8O#!.
-/--;$QTT)# !(D.!1&==S-3-=32
2
# $# $. &D$ #E$ &%. $ < + 8)ED1&D$ D#
--- $ " %$'% .!% S L;-T- Z[!D#+E #!&%#&\ TT %.!)+!
#' +!D+!* '.&%"K]^^_KTT`gqbs^agTO.)#F! K/3-=$Q
83
&* C !& )&!1& B&& 7 .*! "# '
!.)#&!&' "!.! .E ( &# ( #%!'$ .$#
.#%$7!"!#"!C7&#!'*!#&&B +1D'"!&H G
"# B !$ !E '#1$ #!. !& &%.+ "!#E &H
&"#!. "# &%*.G E&#!D'"!&H G'#1$#!.7
"# B !$.#%$E&#!7+C!&F !&%.+!&!$.&$CG&&
D '#!C! !'D7"C!#&D E#E+E&%.#&.#&D$D#"#
#&&'#! 0-$$#*.&D$.!S00L-2;;T%& ID
$.! &%##$E'!# O$#LD QP#%C! !"%D
-2 .$# &%##$$ '!# & ! &1 '!. H &D%G
#$ (H G . "#,*.! "#H!.%#+ &!.& ! ! &"! !G
%D($ )(!1& &%"#%$'LU(D(B D'V "# C&1 &&1
." !1! &$C! ! D .$#%7 (DGB!'% ' & JE
'!. H &DE #$ (H !E #! (H "#$#''+ &%##$$
'!# &7&$&D#'% ' )+"# (!.!."&%''!33
-=#%)!EO!&1" !&%##$E'!# &%"#%$'LU(D(B D'V)+
"# B !+ %)+D #('!#! %D(E &%''+Q ' ' (+&D &
&%##$E'!# "1(%&%"#%$LU(D(B DV&%''+"# B !+, '
%)+D7&%.D*!)(&%##$%G'1D'"!& #1 ''#1+E
#!. #('!#! -3 #%)!E #&.#&D E )&E &%.7
#&&'# C E0-$"!H %G*)%&%##$E'!# 7
"&B 7B.E& %H &13"# '!1&!.*
"J'% B& D'"!&H '#1$ #!. %D(! !C! !
"C!#&D$ #E$ &%. '!
C!'% '! G7 D'
U!#. D!V )&$ &%. "#&D1(+! &D#+! .)#! !
)!(!&!$ C! &%##$E '!# D !! )(&' "
.$#% &%##$$ '!# &7 (L( D#$ &%"#%$ 7 )!(%&7
"#!!#"! #&!+!&#. B !'7B&!.%!"#'
1
"!H !"#!.!! !#&.#&D$D#!$&%.0-$"
$#*.&D'%.!%S 00L-2;;T Z[!D#+E#!&%#&\ TT %.!)+! #' +!
D+!* '.&%"K]^^_KTT`gqbs^agTO.)#F! K-23-=$Q
84
%D(1 ('*&1 D'"!&H '#1$ #!.7 !&!$
&!.& !!.)#&!&$ &"! ! &"! )(!1&
.E ( &# .$# "D J$ ! &.! '* C1
#!D'!.1&%)R!D' &&!.%!'$.$#DGB1!$"*!
)& , #('!#,D'"!&H '#1$#!.
DB!&!& E!&!& &#.$#&%##$$
'!# & *!!1 %D(+1 1D D ! )&!1&7 D#+!
'$% 1.!*F!! &"! !.$#KD(U(D(B DV
"+ ." !1+, #&,. &%##$E '!# 7 GF ,&
!),. '+' .#'1$"#!D )!#!'!& O"# '!#7"#
!),. '& !!,*.! &H #'.!! H!,&,#!
)!#!'!& Q7#%C! !&%##$E'!#1G"O$#I DQ"&!F!
'!. H &DE #$ (H L &" !7 ! &"! ! U(D(B D' V
)(!1&"* (!)!&"!B! G&%##$E'!# .#
# DGB! .$# %D( E "# '!!'+! &DH 7
.%'!&7 . "# &%C 1& D "#!.&!#!*! ' &"!H &
('*' (.!E& & %H GID7D#+!'$%" 1
!('*&1 "# '!! D , &DH E "# '!#7 )#
&!#C! !# %D(+! &!.%GF!!K U& "#!.!!$ ''!
#!'! ('!F! !' %)+D +"E C#I+, &DH E )%.!
!('* && 1 )&  D DD C! )%.%
&*!+)!#!'!&1G %*!#. C '&#!)!D'V
!&!& &# .$# &%##$$ '!# &
"# '!G&)F !"*! )!&!& &%)R!D$#*.&D$
"# )F ' & !' !&!& !& "##%C! !7
!&1 B ! D$ %& DD &!#C! ! .E ( &# .$#
"# "#$ .! 7 +#*GF!$& ! &"!
!.!*F!' &"! & , )(&!E ) (%"#!)!
1
)# !D#+' "#&' )!&"!B! !#!& #!)!D "#
"# '!! !,$ &%##$$'!# &/
85
"#' )!( %* !1E "# B + $!'7 B .! %& !
!&!& &".! C! &!, %B& D $#*.&D ,
"#C! E
+! %& $#*.&DL"#E !&!& %B& D
C! "&%##$'%'!# &% '!G&!.%GF%G&"!H I D%K
D ,C! ,)1C!E&!"! '!!(B! !!#!1!
"# B ! ! #!.7 %$#( D$ "# B ! 7 !&1 "!H 1
('*&1&%"! #!.&+,"&!.& EO"# '!#7&!.& !
!"#!.&! U(D(B D' V !),. '+, .!!*+, &#!.& .
!),. '$ !"$ '!. H &D$ &'# &%##$E '!#
( D%$#("#!#+ )!#!'!& "'!. H &D '"D( 'QM
#!(%1! "# "#$ .! .E ( &# .$#
#!. '*! "# 1& #!)!D!7 #*.!' &%##$E '!#1G7 P
"# '!#7'*!#. 1&&I ( B!&D ' "$ ' &!.& !$7
B &%##$ '1 "!# . )!#!'!& ! "# ' !D#&7
"#!." &+! D "# !'% '!. H &DE #$ (H !E O &" !!'
"#$#''+&%##$$'!# &QM
"# "# !B! &# .$# &%##$$ '!# & D
!&!& '*! &%&1 D! %& ! DD "# B &(1
'!*.%"# "#+'.! !' "# B !+'#!.'7B&& P!&
#!. )+ ! #!1+E7 "!H 1+E O! '!&1 C1 %$#(
"# B ! #!.QM
DD %& ! !&!& C! , &%##$$
'!# & '*! &%&1 )+1 # BE7 !&17 +'
&' 7 '*! ! %B +1& & ' "# '!#! & %H 7 D$.
&%##$'1#%C! !%& E.$#"#!#)!#!'!&1)!(
'!. H &D ,"D( EO!&1"&)&!'%#!C! G&.!)#Q
.E &#+7 #%C! .$# !! .!E& 7 )!(%&7
'!!& & .#%$E &#+7 &%##$ '1 DD G) *!F
).!&%)R!D +'"#'"# !&'&!1$#!C! "
86
".%+C #*.! #!)!DO"#''!# &QM .!
"# !& !! !B%*.!'+' B+' ! '%F!&!+' "#'
( D!"#&K'* $# B 1.!"#&%##$E'!# Y
"# '!#7 D !B! !$ %!#. !1 "#!.$!
$# B 1&%##$%G'1U"#!"#!#+ !)!#!'!& "
&)&!'%*! GV7DDDJ 'U"#!"&%!#! (H "#
'!# & .#%$E *!F + P $!! B!&DE '!# +C !'$
#!)!DV
!& D! $# B! ! ! ."%&D!&7 ( D!
&!.%GF E"#&K'$% U(D(B D V(+&D1 &&%##$E '!#
"# B !+! ' %)+D #!)1 D'"!&H "# B !$ '
'#1$ #!.Y "!H &+ " ) '!. H &D'% "#% !BG
!$&"( H ) J D "J'%%!#*.G7B!1(
-
C
($.7& "# &%C1&D+C!%D('%#$%'!% DE &
"#+,"( H E(DGB 1K"# !.!E& %H "!"# '! '+
%& .$#E !&!& 7 D#+! "# + .)#!+
&%##$E '!#1G ID B!&D (BG !! .)#1+E D(
#! (H &%)R!D $"#O!%D($"#'!# &Q
&G.KC! !!DE& %H '$%"# '!1&$#!+!
.$#! '!#+ !&!& 7DGB D'"!&H G '#1$ #!.7
"# B !$U(D(B D'V
$. &#+ .$# &%##$$ '!# & (G
&#!B+! &D 7 ) .#%$ .#%$ !.!*F!' &"!
)(!1& D7 .!! S 00L-3=T-;7 #&&'#!' --; $
& ) #&D ')&+'&%.'""!H E*)!$#LD
#!C! !!#1$#E$&%.$& ) #&D7)+%&!
&!.%GF!!K %D(+E &%. "!#E &H )# &1 $#LD 89
1
D !$% # ! C! E7 ( DGF , "# "# '!!
&"'$!1+,#!"#.%D +,!,$ E7&!'!E' $#*.&D'"#!&& K
#!I. &D.G# .%D7-
2
4 '!. H &D!"#&& (#%)!*'K'$#I T4'&D E7
#%& 7, .#K#&"!D7-30; &Z[!D#+E#!&%#&\TT
&%" ( &%1G& !* ' .&%"K ]^^_KTTtttsdk`gi^bk^agT O.
)#F! K03-=$Q
87
O&%##$ '1Q & #!) !' (+&D D'"!&H 7
"#!.%&'#!E "%D' -2 .$# &%##$$ '!# &7
(DGB!$&&%"#%$' %"#%$ ( &#!B+E &DD
89(+&D %)+D7"# B !+,! &"! !'.$#%.
"!#E &H %& 7 B U!('*&1 "!#!& J')#
"# (C ! " ! &" ! 8 9V "# &%. (+&D1 &
&%"#%$LU(D(B DV#!)%!'%GD'"!&H GO&!& &.$#'
)+#&&B (D*.+E'!&H"!# .&$%&-3$"I!#1
-$QM%.!#! &D+,#!) E&%"#%$LU(D(B DV)+
UD(7 "&D1D% ! "#!.&! .D(!1& #%C! %& E
.$# &&#+ 8 9V)&E &%.(DGB 7 B7 #(#!C
&"#7 #E+E &%. U"# 1 "#!.! G# . B!&D (B '+!
)&!1&7 . "#%G H!D% %&!+' )&!1&'
"& (D! )&! #!C! !V7 "J'% & J
#!C! !& !7"!H %G*)%P)!(%.!#!
C
($.7"# B E( D! .$&"# &1!.#)D!D&!
.$#%& E)!&!& &#"# '!#7%B& D .$#
!$# 7B" '1". E&%##$E'!# &%B,7D$.
! &%F!&! "!#!& J')# !! #$ ('M &#+ !
DD#! ( # ,#D!# D'"!&H 7 "#!.%&'#!E "%D' -2
.$#7 "J'% #!C! &%. "!#E &H !! (+G
!%&EDE7 .#
"#&+ "# !B! D !&!& .$#, '$%
)%& 1& ''!' B )!#!'!& &%##$E '!#
"# '!#7& J$ ''! .$#''*! %& 1&#!* '.
&%##$E'!# 7"# #%C! D#$"#!.%&'# !&.$#
!&!&1 J'% "#!.$!& DGB 1 #'%
&!.%GF!$ &.!#* K U H!, %#!$% # C! E &#
1
"!H !"#!.!! !& ) #&D$)&$&%.--;$"
$#*.&D'%.!% S 00L-3=T-;Z[!D#+E #!&%#&\ TT%.!)+!#!C!
!* '.&%"K&%.!)+!#!C! #IT0;3-3;Tjo^jkqjqO.)#F! K-3-=$Q
88
&%##$$ '!# & , !&!& ( !.!*F!!
&"! ! ! &"! ! )(!1&7 ( DC , ( .$#
&%##$$ '!# &7 ''!' B )!#!'!& &%##$E
'!# &B !&."!#!&!!#$ ('J')# OJ')# QV
&B &"#+' !& "#& DGB! .$#
&%##$$ '!# & "*! ) !&!& &%##$E
'!# ( D( "!#!.1 #*.!$ !G #!)!D U(D(B D'V C
($.7 #!C! ! &%##$E '!# & 1 #!)!D&!)!&!$.!B!
$%)D !'#1+!&#. .$!! B!&D ,#. !!E<"J'%
".%&!'!C! -2-3$U"#&%"# !'!'& *)+
S30T0’. ' #5(#!O„ibqlrlaubfbajcQ !5(#!O‹bcji
ubfbajcQ "# && E&DE !.!#H ’V &G "( H G )(B
&!.%GF ' )#('K U1 ; !H Zот авт: '!!& .%
!H =3 $\ #!)%! &)G.! H 1+' &'
&"#!. $)&'!*.%DD%# #%GF ' !#!&' 7 B)+"#
"#!.!! D$ )& &)! (B! ! "# .&1 D#!+'
!#!&'#!)!D7D#+!( & '& ,,#D!# *& '$%
'!1"# # !.$ B+' !#!&' #. !!EV
)1C!E
&!"! !#!&' #!)!D7 )!(%&7 &!&%! !$ &" !
#.+' ''E ""EJ'%'+&B !'7B.$#&%##$$
'!# &"!'*DGB 1%& !D'"!&H &%##$E
'!#1G'#1$#!.7"# B !$U(D(B D'V7!,&%B,7D$.
&"1(&1& '"#'& 1#!)!D&!)!
"#D D!&#!BG&&%B 7D$.&%.+&!.%GU)%D!(DV
%F!#) !#!&' &# O .E &#+Q .$# &%##$$
'!# &7 )!! $ P "#' !#!&' #!)!D7 #*.!$
&%##$E '!#1G D7 %C &D E #E+E &%. $ &D+7
1
!C! !<-2-3$U"#&%"# !'!'& *)+S30T0
’. ' #5(#!O„ibqlrlaubfbajcQ !5(#!O‹bcjiubfbajcQ"# && E&DE
!.!#H V Z[!D#+E #!&%#&\ TT !# )+ ".$! . "%) DH
& &!',&%1G& !* ' .&%"K ]^^_KTTtttsdk`gi^bk^agT O. )#F! K
;3-=$Q
89
#&&'# =0-2$$#*.&D!.!S-L2/-T27%& 7B
&#' .$#&%##$$'!# & &1. D E'%*B
&%##$'1# B E)#F! &%.$#L
O$!! B!&D$ H .%, .!B!DL) (C!D7 #*.!+, &%##$E
'!#1GQ "&%* D( %C &D$ .! 8 "#! 8
&D+&!.! E#*.! %D(+,.!!E .%$7B. D E
'%*B !'*!)+1&#E.$#&%##$$'!# &%.
)(J#$8!& D+!(" & #*.! .!B!D7U)!(
%D( &!.! E&%##$E'!# )H!V
J'.!!&&1
!+&!+'7 D ! !.& *! H! &"! .$#
&%##$$ '!# & P U"%B! V $#*. ' & ,
$!! B!&D , .!!E G# . B!&D (D#!"!' & !.1
"%B!&7B.$#&%##$$'!# &!&.!E& !1+'
O&%.!$.*!!"+&"# (1!.!E& !1+'Q7.!*F! &"!7
J'%*B "#'&'+&!H'.!!E$&%.#&'!"# (
+' &' 7 ( D"# D ( K.$#!&17 &"!7
"#+! "&!.& " !'% ! &%" 7 $ J' !
$!'7B# +#(#!C! ".)+,D ( E"# &#!'!'
&& (D.!1& .*+ )+1 "#!.*!+ !#,+'
%.'
<D&!& #$87 (".)+! D(+ #!$ &#H
.!!E7#*.!+,&%##$+' '!#' 7 DDE!&!& !
!&%.*!!,&%B,7D$.& ,&#+."%&D!&#%C! !(D
"# '!#7 !F&D ' .!' 8 $ &D+ )+ D(
#!$ &#H . ,.!!E7#*.!+,&%##$E'!#1G# B E
D("&%* 7B&#!U(D(B DV.$#!&%##$$
'!# &%B&. D*!F 9&!.)# &1&
*)E D( #$ 8 !F&D E #E+E &%. $ &D+7
1
!C! !%C &D$#E$&%.$&D+=0-2$"$#*.&D'%
.!%S-L2/-T2TT#, %C &D$#E$&%.$&D+
90