$!'7B!7DDDD . # .%, !#!&P'!# !!
)1$#!)!DO&.E&#+Q U(D(B DVO&.#%$E&#+Q7L
"# # ! )%.! . &%##$E '!# OD# G# . B!&D &
'!#1G#*.!$!G#!)!DQ #!)!D%
C! '!#!&!& 7"#!.&!&7B$# B! E
!7"#!.%&'# 1& .*+"1*!&%B!'#!) &1
2 B&& 7 "! '* "#!.%&'#!1 D'"!&H G
'#1$ #!.7 !."%& ' !! #&"#&#! ! &%B D(
&%##$E '!# .1 &$& ! (" &1 U(D(B DV #. !'
#*.!$!G#!)!D
& .$# &%##$$ '!# & !& #!,&# '7
&B !'7B!'('*"#!.%&'#!1!&!&1 '!. H &DE
#$ (H DD &" !"#$#''+&%##$$'!# &!EB&
D ! #$ (H BF! "# !DG& ! D $#*.&DL"#E7 D
.' &# E !&!& "# '!#7 --- $ &&D E
)&E&%."# #&&'#! *)+$$#B&%.#&!$
)G.*!$ %B#!*.! &&DE )& U!# 1+E H!#V
%& 7 B )+ U"# ( +' &!#C!
.' &# $"##%C! 7"#!.%&'#!$B0&=-
!'%(B!D( ! .!.' &# $C#I#('!#!
3 #%)!EV &! $7 DD &%. %)!. &7 B J' %B#!*.!
U&%&%! J')# $7 "'!F! ! D# ,# F7 )#%.! .
D# D&!#H ) '!# 7 "'!F! ! . &.B &"!#'+7
"#!.%&'#!+! "#.D' &"1( &"'$!1+,
#!"#.%D +,!,$ EV7%.!#! *)+$#BD(
D ' )#('7 C! &.!#* .$# &%##$$
'!# &'*&.!1&!.%GF !+.+K
1
!C! ! &&D$)&$ &%. ---$".' &# '%
.!%S/L=/T-Z[!D#+E#!&%#&\T%.!)+! #' +!D+!* '
.&%"K]^^_KTT`gqbs^agTO.)#F! K23-=$Q
51
L !),. ' DGB 1 .!1%G $%7 "&F!%G
.$#% &%##$$ '!# &7 $.! )%.% "!#!B &!+ .!1+,
&1,K&%F!&!+!%& J$.$#7D*!"# '!#+E"!#!B!1
." !1+,%& EM
L C ($.7 #(#)D &"1( ! "+, I#'
( #%!'$ .$# ! *!!17 D DD !$ &.!#* ! .*
)+1 . .% ( #+'7 #(#)+' . DD#!+, &#
D$&$C! M
L"# DGB! J.$#%& E)!&!& &#
.*+&)G.1&#!) &1 2
1.4. Исполнение договора суррогатного материнства
$7B)+.$#&%##$$'!# & &"&7"#!*.!
&!$#!)%!&!$I#'! !.!*F!EI#'!.D"#!
#'+7 %D(+GF!E I#'%7 ! &%.!)E "#D D! )+B
"#!.&!& .$#7 &&!+E "#&E " &1'!E I#'!
D%G *! I#'% %D(+!7 "# '!#7 I&1!7 "&D1D% J
.$#U"#*.!&)+!)(!1&'!*.%&#' 7 '!GF !&G
&"!H I D%7.$#!&1D#+, DD!'*!)+1.& $%
%&EI#'!V
'+"..!#* !''! !8#)%'7BU
H!,' ' (H # &D7+(+,"#E!$#'&1G&#V
!),. ' # 1 %.&!#! I#'
-
%'!&7 "#
(D.!1'%&! # 1EI#'+)%.!&%F!&1&
." !1+E D#1 & &#+ $&%.#& H! # %&7
D#+E %.&!# .$# 1D "&! $7 DD "#!# !$
&!& !(D% !#!&'&#!&!7J)%.!1&
." !1E$# !E!$.!*F!$ &"!
1
I&1!D(&B2
2
#)%8 $# &%##$' '!# &! !$ (B! ! & &!'!
(F +"#%B& D#!"#.%D E!,$ TT9& H -/S-3/
52
&" !!'.$#&%##$$'!# &'*!)+11D
H7 .!!! "#' (DGB1 DE .$# "J'% &*
&$& 1&7 "# '!#7 & %!#*.! !' 8! $#.&DE '7 B
&'&!1+' &#' %D($ .$# G& &%"#%$ 7
&%##$'1 '%*&%##$E'!#
$&#'!"%D&
33 & ,#+ (.#1 '%* &%##$E '!# #!)%!& C1
+#*! !&$& !!%B& !.$#!DB!&!&%##$E'!# 7
.$#(DGB!1D
$& "*! ' "%D 0 & 33 & ,#+ (.#1
&#!U(D(B DV.$#!&%##$$'!# &'$%)+1K
L&%"#%$ M
L'%*B *!F 7!&&F !)#D!'!*.%&)EM
L. D*!F
.DD !.$#+(DGBG& +' H' )!!$7
&%.' (DGB!+! .$#+ '$% "# (1& & !.!*F '
&%)R!D+'&&'"#D D! '!'!&.&B (!&+E&%BE7
D#+E)&%*.&!1D"!B+,
-
7 !! .! O
B&& LC%L"#$#''!!!DL0U@ (1DDB%.V
0
Q#E
.%,.$#&%##$''!# &!&1$#*.D5!!C!7
"!#C&!$!. &!$&+P%'!#-;$7(-$..
&!E &'!# &. &"!#'% D# D&!#H G $ '1 #!C
"#!."# 1 '!#+ D #*.! G #.+, %D (DGB .$#
&%##$$ '!# & OG# . B!&D ('*&1 &"1(
D# D&!# #+,) '!# "#!.%&'#!#'E"T"U)V"2
# D(Q7"&!!&D1D ,!%.B+,""+D#! (1&!
*! !&"'F1G"!#E&%##$E'!# D(&1!!%&%$
1
8! $#.&DD(&B;
2
'7 "# '!#K % #B!#D $#I! U'1V O4)%CD B!+#!, %D7
#. C ,&"&!&'!# H7.) !&"#&1 ,'!#1GQTT&& E&D$(!
!.!#1+E+"%&D-$- GS32=0O/Q
3
!!&G*!+5'#!!!C!EU<!!#"D'V U1#% ('&!# V7
"!#+! "D(+! -2 $7 &!EB& '* "&'#!1 I H 1' &E!
!!DL0K]^^_KTT^c0agTclqjdT_admjs^Tf]lfkpbps]gqd
53
.D*! ! '!1%D!%# (DGB .+,.$#
&%##$$ '!# & L & .%' .#%$ ' &%##$+' '!#'
!(%1"%B &!* .+'K#!-$)!*!F +#. "
.E!7 !&1 5 !!C! & ))%CDE &#(% *! B!!#+, #.+,
%D .D "&! J$ B &1 "#)!'+K 5 !!C!7 )!
&%##$+!''+ &" & )(!1&".$#'&%##$$
'!# &"')R!'!M( D"#&!&! D+,(" &!E
#*.! .!!E7DDD4)%CD &D E#E+E.!8$&D+
D(&%D(+1DB!&!H#*.!+,.!!E!!&+O! ,
) $ B!&D$ HQ &! &%.+ O#( B+, %#!EQ7 D#+!
#&&'# ( DC E &"#7 "# ( .$#+7 (DGB!+! 5
!!C!E7.!E& !1+' O!&1!"#!#$ ,DD(DGB!+!&
#%C! !'#!) "0&33&,#+(.#1Q I#'H
.) 'K "#%G D ( G 5 !!C! #(#!C .&B
&!)#(KP%.&1J C1""#C!& .&B. !1$
#!'! 7L%&+ &!,& ,%DO'! 'J'.!! DEG&K
!&'#.&B(#!+E(#&5!!C!E7D#ED''!%
%&+! )+ %*! )!! !7 #$+ "!D ""!B !1&
!& &1D& %H &.*+'" ' !'P&& "* !1!
(DGB! !.D$%&+! Q
& &#E.$#&%##$$'!# &*!!+&%" 1
. D E'%*B OD*!!.!!"#')+1&%)R!D'D$
.$#Q7&%.+DJ'%&&)!!&#*KD#'!D&H
ID!('*& !$%B& J'.$#!&ED(#$%'! #%G
." !1+' & ' "# '!#7!#'E&D E#E+E&%.$
& ) #&D7 D%. )# & $#*. & &D' D
U& ) #&D EH!##!"#.%D E'!. H +V (L(D(D(
!'% '!. H &D , %&%$ & "# '!! !' "#$#''+ &%##$$
'!# & ('!F! %)+D7 %D(7 B &!H ! '*! )+1
&#E .$# &%##$$ '!# & &E D(
54
%.!#! &DU".D#!" V!F!. '#$%'!'K"# '!! !
'!. &%##$$ '!# & ! )+ "%B!" &1'!! &$& !
'%* &%##$E '!# &!H ""+& (F 1 &! "# "%!'
".B "!H E*)+& ) #&D E)&E&%.7 J
&%.!"# !$..+ & #!C! !&%."!#E &H & !7
7&!&!7*)%P)!(%.!#!
+ &B !'7 B C! &%)R!D$ && .$#
&%##$$'!# &#'"%D0&33&,#+(.#1!
.*"# '1& ' !7!& &&#+&%##$E'!# %*!
"#!."# + .!E& D &"! G D$ .$# O ) .$# %*!
&"!"&1GQ('*7 &,. (D$".,.7"# '!#7
!#!)#D "$!7 B U( "'F1G D &%##$E '!# O&%#''!Q
'$% )#F1& &%"#%*!&D ! "#+7 . D ! '%*B +7 . D !
*!F +7!&&F !)#D!V
-
%'!&7B!!'! !.*)+1
"..!#* #&& E&D '(D.!!'!')!!7B"&! &"!
.$# &%##$$ '!# & ( DC ! #. !1&D !
"#C! &%.' "# (G&D7# '#&D E#E+E&%.DL
!!#)%#$"# #&&'#! --;$$#*.&D$.!-L;=T-;
%& 7 B . D E '%*B O &!H " .!%Q '!! . ,
!&!#C!! , .!!E O-/ -; $. #*.! Q7 D#+! )+
#*.!+ & "'F1G '!. &%##$$ '!# &M "J'% ,
& .!!1&,#*.! U$#I!U'1V&"#B!#DV&H%)+
D(+.B!$&%.#&!$&!# I D'!# &D EO&!'!E+EQ
D" .D J &%. (DGB 7 B U C! ! ) $ B!&D$ H
"#"%B! !%D($&!# I D7"# ($"..!#* 1&!,
H7&" +GF ,.%, )!!.!!E7#!'DD'!# 7"# !'+!
#. ! "!D%+ '!G !$ "#7 !&7 " '! G &%.7
1
"!H !"#!.!! !& ) #&D$)&$&%.0--3$"
$#*.&D'%.!%S00L0=-T-3Z[!D#+E#!&%#&\TT%.!)+! #' +!
D+!* '.&%"K]^^_KTT`gqbs^agTO.)#F! K-03-=$Q
2
!#!)#DD(&B30
55
!."%& '+'$&"&0!H "#,#!)!D
&!, .!E& , C! .!!E "!#B!#!.! ' ! .*
%.!1& %BC!'%)!&"!B! G !#!&#!)!DV $!&%.)(
"#! !!& $I.+.1 &H%%D(+E&!# I D
'! 'D*!7BC! &"! .$#!."%& '
&D1&D'+& 7D#%G(%B 7"# '!#74# &K"#!.'!'
.$.$#G&U C1.!E& &%##$E'!# 7D#+!
.)#17 )!( "# %*.! 7 ,.&1 (.#' %'! &E "' 7
&!#C!V
-
# &"! .$#&%##$$'!# &.!E&
&!#CG)!&#+&$C!
F!. &%F!&!+E''!7D&GF E& &"! .$#7
%D(+G9#)!D 9 DK!& . (&#.$#
&%##$$'!# &"#!.& "# !$(DGB! O ).
"&!!$(DGB! Q!.&!#%G I#'H G7 '!GF%G(B! !
'B &! . &"! .$#7DE& %H D#
"$&1 U ".)+! &!.! 7 '*! D(1& .$#
#!)1 "# (1 .$# !.!E& !1+'V O& "# '!! !' #' &
20-Q
0
7!&17 +' &' 7)F!! &"1.$#
#)!'+7 &(+! & &"! !' .$# &%##$$
'!# &7'$%( D%1&%B,7D$. ,%B& D' G&
"#!.& ! !, $&%.#&7 $.! &%##$! '!# & )F! !
#!$% #%!&O, !("#!F!(D'Q!"!"# !'!'EJ'
C! !&"( H .*!D$# !$&%.DD<
C($.7 )!!#D"# &1.!!U…O…Q .#%$ !"#
4!1$ VO*)S-=/T0Q7#&&'#!'<;/-2$%.'
1
!C! ! # '#&D$ #E$ &%. DL!!#)%#$ --; $ "
$#*.&D'%.!%S-L;=T-;Z[!D#+E#!&%#&\TT%.!)+!#!C! !* '
.&%"K&%.!)+!#!C! #IT0/203;Tjo^jkqjqO.)#F! K2-=$Q
2
4# &D(&B
3
#)!D9[D' B!&D&#.$#+,&!'!E+,)(!1&TT
9# &-/S-;M D9# H "+ &"! &!'!E+,.$#+,
)(!1&&!!!$#*.&D$(D.!1&))(!1&,TT!'!E!
* F!"#-3S0=
56
)+ %&!+ &!.%GF ! )&!1&K &%##$! '!# &
)+ #! ( !## # D# +M ( ! &B 7 B )+
."%F! UID B!&D! #(%B! ! , & #!)!D' (L( D( &!E
4!1$ +.1.D%'!7.GF E!'%"#R!(.&#%7B"# !
D #(#+% C! E '!*.% $#%.+' #!)!D' (#&! !&D1D ,
!.!1 !$#. !' VMDED(U&!E4!1$ V)+)%&!7
'B &!7U(F E"#.#%$ , H7.'&%B!"#&%##$E
'!# V #*.!$!G#!)!D<%D(7B!H =3$U!
)(+! $&%.#&L%B& D #(#!C1 R!(. &G !## # G
.!!E7 #. C ,& &%##$E '!# 7 !& %# $&%.#&!+!
& !&& "#!& "#!.# !1%G!),. '%G&%.!)%G
"#!#D%4!1$ !'*!!& !&!& (7B( !'
&*)+(.!#*1&D# ! &1&'&!#!'7!B! !
D#$ .! #&&'# &1 &%.' 4!1$ V $! *) )+
"# ( U!"# !'!'E . #&&'#! " &%F!&% ODD
!)&QV
$!'7 B ".) & %H '*! )+1 &( ! 1D &
D# E +' $&%.#&'7 & && !E #!.&!&7 B
#(#!C 1 "#)!'+7 &(+! & &"! !' .$# &%##$$
'!# && &#+'%B& !'7('*7DD%*!'!B&1+C!7
1D "&#!.&' (DGB! '!*.%#.$ .$# &%##$'
'!# &!D !'!*.%#.+!&$C! "!#%GB!#!.1"(
%BC ' )#(' )!&"!B 1 "# !#!&+ !, .!!E7 D#+!
#. &1#!(%1! &"! .$#&%##$''!# &!7
$!P&'$%$# #1#! (H G ,"#"#* !&!'1!
& ,$!! B!&D ,#. !!E
'E&*E #%.#(#!C 'E"#)!'E!&7D#
)+B( D!"&!#*.! #!)!DKD&!&+#*! &$&
1
I#'H !C! <;/-2$".!%U…O…Q .#%$ !"#
4!1$ VO*)S-=/T0QTT4G!!1#"!E&D$%.""#'B!!D-2
S-
57
O !&$& Q &%##$E '!# (" &1 DB!&! #. !!E
#*.!$ !G #!)!D U(D(B DV O U(D(B DV7 !& DE
!& . D *!F Q "! !&!&!7 B U(D(B D V
"#!&!.%G &G &%)R!D %G H!1 P U"%B 1V &!$ #!)!D7
#*.!$&"'F1G
!E&%GF '(D.!1&' &"! ! .$# &%##$$
'!# & JE B& #!$'! # 1D C!
U(D(B DV7D#+!G&&%"#%$' O)(-"2&3Q!&1
#' +!"*! 7D&GF !&U(D(B DV H!!&&F ,
)#D!'%*B + *!F + . DE*!F +7&%&%G&G.K
C ($.7 .' &%B! . #%D.&1& " $
"*! ' &3 "0&3 "# (. 1(" &1!!'!# &!
H!''*!"#.D!7D#+E%&!.&%"#%$
&!'+E (#' &,#+(.#1"(!
(DGB 17B&+'%& !'(" & &%"#%$DB!&!#. !!E
#!)!D7#*.!$&%##$E'!#1G7!&$!! B!&D!#.&&
#!)!D' , )+ .$ ( &%"#%$ #+' %& !' &B !&
&!.%GF!!K !F! . DGB! "#$#''% &%##$$ '!# &
(DGB! .$#&%##$''!# &!&%"#%$ .*+.1U&!
&$& !" &1'!EI#'! '"H GJ')# .#%$E*!F !
H!,!$ +C VO)( - " 2 & 3 Q !&!7"
$ 7 . DE *!F ! *! . '!1 $!! B!&D! #.& &
#!)!D' D*! D'*!"#.D!+#( 1%D(!&$& !
G)' &%B! D (" &1 &!EB& ('* 1D &
&)G.! !' #!) E )(H - " 2 & 3 7 ! & &$&
&%##$E '!# ".% .$ "# )+B '!
&"!H &. '!#1"# "*+KB&1 ( ,&B !D%G
#DD% &"#!. E7 B&1 P "# 7 "$!7 B D
D!$# B&1!B!&!$(D.!#%C!"#$!! B!&D ,
#. !!E#!)!D7#*.!$&%##$E'!#1GU&!+D*!
58
ID+ +'$!1& & &#+ &%##$E '!# % ) $ B!&D ,
#. !!E7D#&"!D% #%!'7B'*!!.1&$& (" &1
,#. !' #!)!DV
D! #(! C! !7 C ($.7 )1CE &!"!
)R&!& &!.%GF 'K $!&H !# 7 D# #. H
"# '!!&&& 7"#!."$!7DD!#'!B!D# 7B
*!EC ' & !' ( D! #. !1&D , "# "# (!&
)!#!'!&1
-
7.%'!&7&#( !'C!E&#!."&!"!
"!#!&1&"# '1J%!# GDB!&!!. &!!#E7DDD
,. "# #!B !& !#!&' $!! B!&D ,#. !!E#!)!D7
#*.!$&%##$E'!#1GJ%D(+! #. &&!.!!EM
"# '!#79 D'CKU!& #!!"# H " rb^jaj`^ •gbrnj`^b^ld
qjrdk`^ab^jOU'1L7B"# (!#!)!D&!VQ %D$!+(+
&'! E7 &!$.C E .!1 #.! & %H E ! !&
"#!.!GF ' !. &!!#+'V
0
D *!7DD ".B!#D !
I&1!7(D"(!&%##$E'!# DDU$!&H '%D%#1!#%
! 1D )!(D( ! &"1 .$#+! )(!1&7
"!(D+,& ,U(.!1V) $ B!&D B%* '#!)!D'V
2
!&17 +' &' 7&%##$'1U!'*!)+1"%*.!DDD
"!#!.B! #*.!$ #!)!D7 D D +#*! G &$& (" &1
#. !' #!)!D &%"#%$7 "# C , %B& ! '"H
J')# V
3
1
4B!# , 7 4.#! #)!'+! "#&+ "#$
#!$% # &%##$$ '!# & && E&DE !.!#H TT ! !H #!
"#KG# . B!&D!# "#"# '! !1"#D D-=SO=Q;-
2
D# # "# #. C! E '!*.% &%##$E '!#1G
#*.!+'!G#!)!D'TT!. H &D!"#--S30/
3
D'C 9 "#&% !),. '& "%B! $!! B!&D '
#. !' &$& &%##$E'!# ."# )#!! #. !1&D ,"##!)!D
TT!'!E! * F!"#-0S2
4
I&1! #*.&D "#H!&&%1 &# .! ) &"!
.$# "#!.&! %&%$ &%##$$ '!# & TT #) #*+E
$#*.&D E"#H!&&-2S/-;P-=
5
4#G,4$#&%##$''!# &!"(D.!1&%&& 7
(,& 4!#%&& TT <&! "# #!.! &"+ L! G 4
$T4.744#G,7!! .#K%7-0
59
+&B !'7B"#$ '7BU%&%##$E'!# !
'*! !.*)+1 DD ,"#! '%F!&7!'*!.!1&
"#' 7 ! &E&!+' !! &%&%7 "#!.!1 &%.1)% #!)!D7
D#$!(B71D+& 7!.!#!$!E#!'
1D.&#$"#!.!!EH! V
. .%1+!"( H "
J'% ".%+ !D#+!&%.1 & %H $%. M
B&& K
L"'! G&%.1 (!7U(D.!1&!&)!(%B&+'
D !#!&' H7B1 "+!D!D &"1( &1.".#!
*!F +7+C GF!E".!'&'+'&(.!&!$1"B.
#%C! )&D& %H +,H!&!E %'! "# (D+,
!#!&!1D$!! B!&D ,#. !!E7 #!)!D7#*.!$
#!(%1!"# '!! &!&%GF!E&"'$!1E#!"#.%D E
!,$ V
-
M
L &%.1 .* ! "$!7 B U&"#+' &!& "#&
D " ’'1#!)!D’A!& &%##$'1'!#1G
D& %H '&'+&!YV
0
7!#D%#&!#'&1 0;& %H
H!' & %H +E %. "# .!#* !& DE "( H K
#')(H-"2&3!"# #!B & %H .*
&)G.1&[)+"#.!'&# #7"# '!#7!$"#!.!!
-/=-;$S-0;LK"# D#&&'#! G*)+$#*.
)+D(
2
1
$ D(&B;
2
! ! &%.1 & %H $ %. && E&DE !.!#H (!
Z[!D#+E#!&%#&\TT"#!.!! !& %H $%.33--$S;;L
&%" ( &%1G& !* ' .&%"K ]^^_KTTtttsdk`gi^bk^agT O.
)#F! K03-=$Q
3
! ! &%.1 & %H $ %. && E&DE !.!#H .* !
Z[!D#+E#!&%#&\TT"#!.!! !& %H $%.33--$S;;L
&%" ( &%1G& !* ' .&%"K ]^^_KTTtttsdk`gi^bk^agT O.
)#F! K03-=$Q
4
"#!.!! ! & %H $ %. -/=-; $ S -0;L
Z[!D#+E#!&%#&\TTD%'!"%) D!)+&%1G&!* '
.&%"K]^^_KTTtttsdk`gi^bk^agTO.)#F! K--=$Q
60